I'm thinking these two questions will be of interest to many, with the R2 deadline only about a month away for HBS!
1) Is there any best approach or guidance on how to shortlist your ECs to your top three? Should we be picking from our best ECs whether they were post-college or during college? Should we consider recreational/hobby-type ECs or only community-type ECs? Basically, how should we go about short-listing?
2) When picking awards, should we be highlighting our three very best, even if we know some of them will be highlighted elsewhere in the application? For example, I know my manager will talk about an important piece of professional recognition, should I mention this anyway? As another example, would it make sense for these top three to also be included on your resume? Basically, how should we go about short-listing, and how to handle overlap with other application parts?
Thanks to all who have thoughts on this!