Historian: In the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, the Swahili civilization of East Africa built tombs with large pillars and paneled facades. Such structures are widespread among the Oromo people of Somalia and Kenya, but are unknown among any other people with whom the Swahili civilization had contact. This indicates that Swahili culture was, to some extent, influenced by Oromo culture.
The historian's argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that itThe historian sees a structure common among the Oromo and also present among the Swahili, but absent among other peoples the Swahili contacted. From this, the historian concludes that the Swahili were influenced by the Oromo.
The key flaw is that the argument assumes the Oromo had this architectural style
before the Swahili did. Without that timing, the influence could have gone the other way.
(A) fails to address adequately the possibility that the Oromo people did not use the structures as tombs
This is not the main flaw. Even if the Oromo used similar structures for something other than tombs, the shared architectural form could still suggest influence.
(B) concludes, simply because one event occurred earlier than another event, that the first event caused the second event
This is incorrect. The argument does not establish that one event occurred earlier than another. In fact, the problem is that the timing is missing.
(C) draws a restricted conclusion from premises that provide strong support for a much broader conclusion
This is incorrect. The conclusion is already cautious: “to some extent” influenced. The problem is not that the conclusion is too narrow.
(D) takes for granted that there was no third civilization responsible for creating the first tombs of the kind found in both the Oromo and Swahili cultures
This is tempting, but less direct. The passage says the structures are unknown among any other people with whom the Swahili had contact, so a third-civilization explanation is less supported by the setup.
(E) takes for granted that the Oromo people began constructing tombs with large pillars and paneled facades earlier than the Swahili civilization did
This is correct. To conclude that Oromo culture influenced Swahili culture, the historian needs the Oromo version to have existed first. Otherwise, the Swahili might have influenced the Oromo, or both might have developed the structures independently.
Answer: (E)