Official Solution: Bunuel
For each of the following statements about the recall scores in Tab 3, select
Yes if the statement accurately reflects the information provided. Otherwise, select
No.
Statement 1: All four experimental groups scored at least four times as much as the control group on every test.
Control scores: 20 (immediate), 12 (1 day), 5 (1 week)
Four times those values: 80, 48, 20.
• Immediate: Flashcard (82), Discussion (74), Silent (68), Video (64). Only Flashcard ≥ 80. Others < 80.
• 1 day: Experimental groups (71, 64, 50, 43). Three ≥ 48, but Video is 43 < 48.
• 1 week: Experimental groups (55, 59, 28, 22). All ≥ 20.
So it is not true that
all four groups scored ≥ four times control on
every test.
Answer: No Statement 2: The average decline across the four experimental groups from the immediate test to the one-day test was smaller than the average decline from the one-day test to the one-week test.
We need to compute average declines.
•
Immediate → 1 day: Flashcard: 82 – 71 = 11
Silent: 68 – 50 = 18
Video: 64 – 43 = 21
Discussion: 74 – 64 = 10
Average decline = (11 + 18 + 21 + 10) / 4 = 60 / 4 = 15 •
1 day → 1 week: Flashcard: 71 – 55 = 16
Silent: 50 – 28 = 22
Video: 43 – 22 = 21
Discussion: 64 – 59 = 5
Average decline = (16 + 22 + 21 + 5) / 4 = 64 / 4 = 16 Compare: 15 (first drop) vs 16 (second drop).
Yes, the average decline from Immediate → 1 day is smaller than from 1 day → 1 week.
Answer: Yes Statement 3: At least one group outperformed another group at the immediate test but scored lower than that same group at the one-week test.
This means:
• At the Immediate stage, Group A > Group B.
• At the One-week stage, Group A < Group B.
• In other words, the two groups switched order between Immediate and One-week.
Check Tab 3:
•
Flashcard vs Group Discussion: Immediate → Flashcard (82) > Discussion (74).
One week → Flashcard (55) < Discussion (59).
Switch occurs.
Thus, the statement is true.
Answer: Yes Correct answer: All four experimental groups scored at least four times as much as the control group on every test.
"No"The average decline across the four experimental groups from the immediate test to the one-day test was smaller than the average decline from the one-day test to the one-week test.
"Yes"At least one group outperformed another group at the immediate test but scored lower than that same group at the one-week test.
"Yes"