Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 44566

If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
01 May 2015, 02:10
Question Stats:
33% (01:43) correct 67% (01:39) wrong based on 133 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics



Current Student
Joined: 24 Mar 2015
Posts: 35
Concentration: General Management, Marketing
GPA: 3.21
WE: Science (Pharmaceuticals and Biotech)

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
01 May 2015, 11:19
5
This post received KUDOS
3
This post was BOOKMARKED
Bunuel wrote: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX, and QX are integers, what is the area of the circle? (1) (AX)(BX) = 16 (2) QX > AB Kudos for a correct solution.We must find the radius or the diameter length in this problem to provide sufficient data to answer the question posed. 1) No information regarding how to find the raidus or diameters actual length only the potential lengths of line AB. Not Sufficient. 2) No information regarding the scale of the circle or the lines. Not Sufficient. Now in order to assess them together we need to look at how the lines relate to each other. If you draw an imaginary line from A to P and B to Q you notice that they form similar triangles as they each have a vertex at the end of the circles diameter. With this information we have the ratio of the lines as sides of similar triangles AX/QX=PX/BX Cross Multiply to get (AX)(BX)=(PX)(QX) From statement 1 we can see that (AX)(BX)=16=(PX)(QX) Since AX and BX are integer lengths that must calculate to a product of 16 giving us the potential length pairs of 1 & 16, 2 & 8, or 4 & 4 in any order. This also tells us that the minimum length of the AB will be 8 (4+4). Since we know (AX)(BX)=(PX)(QX) we have the same potential length pairs as above. Since statement 2 tells us that QX>AB QX must be greater than 8 giving us the only option that it must be 16. The paired length with 16 as shown above is 1 so PX+QX=16+1=17 17 is the diameter of the circle which is sufficient information to calculate the area. Select answer choice C.
_________________
Please pass me a +KUDOS if you liked my post! Thanks!
Do not compare yourself to others, compare yourself to who you were yesterday.



Manager
Joined: 01 Jan 2015
Posts: 56

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
02 May 2015, 14:09
1
This post received KUDOS
Agles AXP and QXB are vertical opposite angles, so they are equal. AX/QX = PX/BX  (EQ1) NOW ST 1 (AX)(BX) = 16 so the values can be 8x2;4x4;16x1 hence NS ST 2 QX>AB so what NS Combining A&B Now the min. value of AB = 8 and (AX)(BX)=(PX)(QX) hence min value of PQ will be 8 but St 2 says QX>AB this is only possible when (PX)(QX) = 16x1 hence PQ = dia = 16+1 = 17 Area = pie(r^2) and r = 17/2 HENCE C



Intern
Joined: 06 Apr 2015
Posts: 7

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
03 May 2015, 08:43
funkyleaf wrote: Bunuel wrote: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX, and QX are integers, what is the area of the circle? (1) (AX)(BX) = 16 (2) QX > AB Kudos for a correct solution.We must find the radius or the diameter length in this problem to provide sufficient data to answer the question posed. 1) No information regarding how to find the raidus or diameters actual length only the potential lengths of line AB. Not Sufficient. 2) No information regarding the scale of the circle or the lines. Not Sufficient. Now in order to assess them together we need to look at how the lines relate to each other. If you draw an imaginary line from A to P and B to Q you notice that they form similar triangles as they each have a vertex at the end of the circles diameter. With this information we have the ratio of the lines as sides of similar triangles AX/QX=PX/BX Cross Multiply to get (AX)(BX)=(PX)(QX) From statement 1 we can see that (AX)(BX)=16=(PX)(QX) Since AX and BX are integer lengths that must calculate to a product of 16 giving us the potential length pairs of 1 & 16, 2 & 8, or 4 & 4 in any order. This also tells us that the minimum length of the AB will be 8 (4+4). Since we know (AX)(BX)=(PX)(QX) we have the same potential length pairs as above. Since statement 2 tells us that QX>AB QX must be greater than 8 giving us the only option that it must be 16. The paired length with 16 as shown above is 1 so PX+QX=16+1=17 17 is the diameter of the circle which is sufficient information to calculate the area. Select answer choice C. im not seeing how the two triangles are similar. i get that AXP and BXQ are vertical angles, but cant find any relation between the other two angles.



Senior Manager
Joined: 28 Feb 2014
Posts: 295
Location: United States
Concentration: Strategy, General Management

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
03 May 2015, 12:01
The length of AB is at 8, 10 or 17.
the condition QX > AB is only possible if QX = 16 Why is this so? Cant QX also be any integer greater than 16?
Not understanding the steps here to get to 17 as the diameter........



Intern
Joined: 04 May 2015
Posts: 3

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
08 May 2015, 05:17
how can we say that the two triangles formed are similar?? we are given that only measure of one angle is same in both triangles which is insufficient to prove congruency.. please explain



Current Student
Joined: 24 Mar 2015
Posts: 35
Concentration: General Management, Marketing
GPA: 3.21
WE: Science (Pharmaceuticals and Biotech)

If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
08 May 2015, 10:49
gmatusamba wrote: how can we say that the two triangles formed are similar?? we are given that only measure of one angle is same in both triangles which is insufficient to prove congruency.. please explain Hi there, you seem to be not the only one with confusion on this so I will do my best to explain. Firstly it primarily has to do with the fact that vertices of each triangle is formed at the ends of the diameter of the circle they are inscribed within. Since the line AB intersects the circle (and its diameter) it is sufficient to say that these angles are similar within the triangles as well. If two angles of triangles are the same measurement then the third must also be the same making them similar triangles. A more visualization approach that may help illuminate this fact is as follows. If you were to draw a line exactly perpendicular to the diameter at exactly point X then fold the circle at both the diameter and the perpendicular line you would have two triangles perfectly inscribed with the longest sides (BQ and AP) exactly parallel with each other. All of the angles would either overlap or be the same giving us similar triangles for comparison. You just have to remember that similar triangles can be manipulated visually to fit ontop of one another. This is a very sorry if this does not clarify it. This is a very tricky problem and I honestly doubt that this is a real question that you could expect to see on the actual test.
_________________
Please pass me a +KUDOS if you liked my post! Thanks!
Do not compare yourself to others, compare yourself to who you were yesterday.



Intern
Joined: 07 Mar 2014
Posts: 21

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
12 May 2015, 06:46
funkyleaf wrote: gmatusamba wrote: how can we say that the two triangles formed are similar?? we are given that only measure of one angle is same in both triangles which is insufficient to prove congruency.. please explain Hi there, you seem to be not the only one with confusion on this so I will do my best to explain. Firstly it primarily has to do with the fact that vertices of each triangle is formed at the ends of the diameter of the circle they are inscribed within. Since the line AB intersects the circle (and its diameter) it is sufficient to say that these angles are similar within the triangles as well. If two angles of triangles are the same measurement then the third must also be the same making them similar triangles. A more visualization approach that may help illuminate this fact is as follows. If you were to draw a line exactly perpendicular to the diameter at exactly point X then fold the circle at both the diameter and the perpendicular line you would have two triangles perfectly inscribed with the longest sides (BQ and AP) exactly parallel with each other. All of the angles would either overlap or be the same giving us similar triangles for comparison. You just have to remember that similar triangles can be manipulated visually to fit ontop of one another. This is a very sorry if this does not clarify it. This is a very tricky problem and I honestly doubt that this is a real question that you could expect to see on the actual test. I will give it a shot. In general a secent(segment ) rule says that the product of cords that intersect are equal. Proof does stem from the fact that the triangles in discussion are similar. Google it and you will find the proof. Here is one site you can explore different circle rules. http://www.regentsprep.org/regents/math ... gments.htmIn nutshull we have a relation of intersection cords that will be helpful to remember on GMAt rather than proof. Same has been used here : Px. QX = AX.BX. Based on this theorem the question is solved.



Manager
Joined: 25 Nov 2009
Posts: 57
Location: India

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Jan 2017, 03:02
I think it's pretty well explained from the Data Sufficiency angle. So, not solving the entire problem. But just adding a bit on the first part of the explanation related to the concepts of Intersecting Chords & Similarity. To understand the problem in a better way let us remember the following rules/ theorems. 1) Theorem related to Intersection of Chords: When two chords intersect each other inside a circle, then each is divided into 2 segments and the products of their segments are equal. Thus in this question, when we consider the chords AB and PQ (note: Diameter is the largest chord of a circle), they intersect at X. Hence AX . BX = PX . QX You can straightaway apply this to proceed with this question. 2) Theorem related to Angles subtended by an Arc on the Circle: Angles subtended on the circumference in the same segment of a circle by the same arc are always equal (note: These are call Internal Angles, and are half of the Central Angle subtended by the same arc at the centre of the circle). Thus in this question if we consider the arc PA, it subtends two angles  one at B and another at Q. Hence, angle(PAB) = angle(PQB) Now if you consider the two triangles, PAX and QBX, then they have angle(PAB) = angle(PQB) ..... as shown above angle(PXA) = angle(QXB) ..... vertically opposite angles And hence they are SIMILAR (note: two triangles are similar if all the three angles are equal and in fact if two sets of angles are equal, then automatically the third set of angles must also be equal). Thus their "Corresponding Sides" will be in the same Ratio (note: by Corresponding sides I refer to the sides opposite to the equal angles in two similar triangles). So, AX/ QX = PX/ BX i.e. AX . BX = PX . QX Again we arrive at the same results as in Point 1 and can proceed from there. Although I would prefer a student to straightaway go for method 1, I thought of discussing the method 2 since the concept of Similarity was already discussed in context to this problem and I think all can develop good insights by understanding this approach.
Attachments
Circle_Intersecting Chords_DIKSHA_GMAT GRE_Kolkata.jpg [ 56.5 KiB  Viewed 680 times ]



Manager
Joined: 07 May 2015
Posts: 94

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Jan 2017, 03:44
jusjmkol740 wrote: I think it's pretty well explained from the Data Sufficiency angle. So, not solving the entire problem. But just adding a bit on the first part of the explanation related to the concepts of Intersecting Chords & Similarity. To understand the problem in a better way let us remember the following rules/ theorems.
1) Theorem related to Intersection of Chords: When two chords intersect each other inside a circle, then each is divided into 2 segments and the products of their segments are equal. Thus in this question, when we consider the chords AB and PQ (note: Diameter is the largest chord of a circle), they intersect at X. Hence AX . BX = PX . QX You can straightaway apply this to proceed with this question.
2) Theorem related to Angles subtended by an Arc on the Circle: Angles subtended on the circumference in the same segment of a circle by the same arc are always equal (note: These are call Internal Angles, and are half of the Central Angle subtended by the same arc at the centre of the circle). Thus in this question if we consider the arc PA, it subtends two angles  one at B and another at Q. Hence, angle(PAB) = angle(PQB)
Now if you consider the two triangles, PAX and QBX, then they have angle(PAB) = angle(PQB) ..... as shown above angle(PXA) = angle(QXB) ..... vertically opposite angles And hence they are SIMILAR (note: two triangles are similar if all the three angles are equal and in fact if two sets of angles are equal, then automatically the third set of angles must also be equal). Thus their "Corresponding Sides" will be in the same Ratio (note: by Corresponding sides I refer to the sides opposite to the equal angles in two similar triangles). So, AX/ QX = PX/ BX i.e. AX . BX = PX . QX Again we arrive at the same results as in Point 1 and can proceed from there.
Although I would prefer a student to straightaway go for method 1, I thought of discussing the method 2 since the concept of Similarity was already discussed in context to this problem and I think all can develop good insights by understanding this approach. hi there, Can you please help me understand why can't the ax.bx be equal to 1x16 (or vice versa) why does it has to be 8x2 (or vice versa)? Thanks in advance!



Manager
Joined: 25 Nov 2009
Posts: 57
Location: India

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Jan 2017, 04:55
Sure "neeraj609". Now we know, AX . BX = PX . QX From St 1, we know AX . BX = 16; So, PX . QX is also 16. Since all these have integer values, hence options can be (1, 16), (2, 8) or (4, 4) Our interest is to find the Diameter (PQ = PX + QX) With all 3 possible values of (PX, QX), PQ can also have 3 values: 17, 10 and 8 Thus, Statement 1 is not sufficient.
St 2 doesn't give us anything at all. So even that is not sufficient by itself.
Note, AB can also have 3 values: 17, 10 and 8 (with varying integer pairs following AX.BX = 16) And possible values of QX are 1, 2, 4, 8, 16 (note: corresponding values of PX will be 16, 8, 4, 1 to ensure PX.QX = 16)
If we combine St 1 and St 2, to satisfy QX > AB, QX must be 16 (and AB must be 8 in that case). When QX = 16, PX will be 1. So diameter PQ will be 17. And we can find the Area of the Circle.
Hope it helps. If not please write back.
# This is a brilliant problem that works on so many concepts of Geometry all at the same time and is very much within the scope of GMAT. But it's actually difficult to solve in realtime exam.



NonHuman User
Joined: 09 Sep 2013
Posts: 6637

Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX [#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Mar 2018, 20:41
Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot! Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up  doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos). Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________
GMAT Books  GMAT Club Tests  Best Prices on GMAT Courses  GMAT Mobile App  Math Resources  Verbal Resources




Re: If PQ is a diameter of the circle above, and the lengths of AX, BX, PX
[#permalink]
16 Mar 2018, 20:41






