The key idea:
When you add the same positive number b to both the numerator and denominator,
x/y → (x+b)/(y+b)
the new fraction moves closer to 1.
Why?
Because the numerator and denominator become more similar.
----------------------------------------------------------
Case 1: Fraction less than 1
2/5 = 0.4
Add 3 to both:
(2+3)/(5+3) = 5/8 = 0.625
The fraction got bigger and moved closer to 1.
Therefore:
If x/y < 1, then (x+b)/(y+b) > x/y
----------------------------------
Case 2: Fraction greater than 1
5/2 = 2.5
Add 3 to both:
(5+3)/(2+3) = 8/5 = 1.6
The fraction got smaller and moved closer to 1.
Therefore:
If x/y > 1, then (x+b)/(y+b) < x/y
----------------------------------
GMAT Shortcut:
If a fraction is less than 1, adding the same number to the numerator and denominator makes it larger.
If a fraction is greater than 1, adding the same number to the numerator and denominator makes it smaller.
In both cases, the fraction moves toward 1.
Key Rule
Start with x/y.
Add a to the numerator and b to the denominator:
(x + a)/(y + b)
The new fraction moves closer to a/b.
Decision Rule
If x/y < a/b, the fraction increases.
If x/y > a/b, the fraction decreases.
If x/y = a/b, the fraction stays the same.
Example 1
Start: 2/7
Add 3 to numerator and 5 to denominator.
Target fraction = 3/5.
Since 2/7 < 3/5, the new fraction is larger:
2/7 < 5/12
Example 2
Start: 11/12
Add 2 to numerator and 5 to denominator.
Target fraction = 2/5.
Since 11/12 > 2/5, the new fraction is smaller:
11/12 > 13/17
GMAT Shortcut
Compare the original fraction x/y with a/b.
If x/y < a/b → fraction goes up.
If x/y > a/b → fraction goes down.
If x/y = a/b → no change.
Think of (x + a)/(y + b) as a weighted average of x/y and a/b, so it always moves toward a/b.
Key rule:
(x+2)/(y+3) moves toward 2/3.
Need to know whether x/y is above or below 2/3.
(1) y > 20
No information about x. x/y could be above or below 2/3.
Insufficient.
(2) x < 5
No information about y. x/y could be above or below 2/3.
Insufficient.
Together:
x < 5 and y > 20
Largest possible fraction is 4/21.
Since 4/21 < 2/3, x/y < 2/3 always.
Moving toward 2/3 means the fraction increases.
Definite answer: Yes.
Answer = C.
Key rule:
(x+5)/(y+5) moves toward 1.
Need to know whether x/y is above or below 1.
(1) y = 5
No information about x.
x/y could be less than or greater than 1.
Insufficient.
(2) x > y
Since x/y > 1, the fraction is above 1.
Moving toward 1 makes the fraction smaller.
Definite answer: No.
Sufficient.
Answer = B.