Last visit was: 20 Jul 2024, 09:42 It is currently 20 Jul 2024, 09:42
Close
GMAT Club Daily Prep
Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track
Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History
Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.
Close
Request Expert Reply
Confirm Cancel
SORT BY:
Date
Tags:
Show Tags
Hide Tags
Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 94430
Own Kudos [?]: 642521 [2]
Given Kudos: 86708
Send PM
Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 94430
Own Kudos [?]: 642521 [1]
Given Kudos: 86708
Send PM
Senior Manager
Senior Manager
Joined: 10 Apr 2018
Posts: 340
Own Kudos [?]: 201 [1]
Given Kudos: 217
Concentration: Leadership, Strategy
GMAT 1: 600 Q44 V28
GPA: 3.56
WE:Engineering (Computer Software)
Send PM
Director
Director
Joined: 16 Jun 2021
Posts: 976
Own Kudos [?]: 187 [0]
Given Kudos: 309
Send PM
Re: It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera de [#permalink]
Bunuel wrote:
It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera derives from the camera obscura, usually credited to the Arab scientist Abu Ali Al-Hasan Ibn al-Haitham in the eleventh century. Working in an early version of a dark room, Ibn al-Haitham studied the movement of light and discovered that he could reproduce images by reflecting light through pinholes. Prior to Ibn al-Haitham, though, the Chinese philosopher Mozi had already begun developing a variety of a
pinhole camera in the fourth century BC. Later in that same century, both Aristotle and Euclid remarked on the placement of light when projected through pinholes. What is more, the Arab mathematician Abu Yusuf Ya‘qub Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi became the first to project images with an early type of camera obscura in the ninth century. As a result, although Ibn al-Haitham is often credited with the creation of the camera obscura, he is also recorded as having said that he did not invent it.

The claims made in the passage above, if true, support which of the following statements?


+1 for B

(A) Though Ibn al-Haitham is given credit for inventing the camera obscura in the eleventh century, it was invented by Mozi in the fourth century BC.
Mozi inly developed or rather lais sown a few imporatant features so we cannot entirely bestow the credit to Mozi

(B) Ibn al-Haitham’s development of the camera obscura in the eleventh century was the result of discoveries in previous centuries that contributed to his research.
This feels promising since Ibn admits that he didn't invent it completly this might hint towards the fact that he took cues from others individually therefore let us hang on to it

(C) The Greek philosophers Aristotle and Euclid developed their experiments on the pinhole camera from the writings of the Chinese philosopher Mozi.
We cannot be absolutely sure since they might have individually developed for example Newton and leibnitz developed calculus individually without the aid of reference of anyone

(D) Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi is unfairly overlooked as the real inventor of the camera obscura.
unfairly fair are all subjective terms therefore we can give one look and eleminate

(E) Though usually considered a modern development, the camera was really invented in the eleventh century
camera obscura was developed and not itself was developed

Therefore IMO D
Director
Director
Joined: 16 Jun 2021
Posts: 976
Own Kudos [?]: 187 [0]
Given Kudos: 309
Send PM
It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera de [#permalink]
TheGraceful wrote:
Hi Bunuel,
Although its official explanation that says B is the correct answer choice, I am NOT convinced and am doubtful about the explanation.

Since I agree with explanations for answer choices A, C and E, I will discuss only about B and D here.

(B) Ibn al-Haitham’s development of the camera obscura in the eleventh century was the result of discoveries in previous centuries that contributed to his research.
==> This can NOT be inferred from the para/passage. Although some work was made on presursor of camera, but it can NOT be said that contributed to Ibn al-Haitham's work. Ibn al-Haitham independently discovered the thing.
Let's have a look at para (highlighted)


Bunuel wrote:
It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera derives from the camera obscura, usually credited to the Arab scientist Abu Ali Al-Hasan Ibn al-Haitham in the eleventh century. Working in an early version of a dark room, Ibn al-Haitham studied the movement of light and discovered that he could reproduce images by reflecting light through pinholes. Prior to Ibn al-Haitham, though, the Chinese philosopher Mozi had already begun developing a variety of a pinhole camera in the fourth century BC. Later in that same century, both Aristotle and Euclid remarked on the placement of light when projected through pinholes. What is more, the Arab mathematician Abu Yusuf Ya‘qub Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi became the first to project images with an early type of camera obscura in the ninth century. As a result, although Ibn al-Haitham is often credited with the creation of the camera obscura, he is also recorded as having said that he did not invent it.

As for his saying of he did NOT invent it, doesn't concretely mean his predecessors did it, he could have wanted to share the credit with any of his assistant, friend, family member, pet that made.



(D) Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi is unfairly overlooked as the real inventor of the camera obscura.
Since other options are eliminated this becomes our answer. Moreover, look at the passage (highlited the things) that supports this option.
Bunuel wrote:
It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera derives from the camera obscura, usually credited to the Arab scientist Abu Ali Al-Hasan Ibn al-Haitham in the eleventh century. Working in an early version of a dark room, Ibn al-Haitham studied the movement of light and discovered that he could reproduce images by reflecting light through pinholes. Prior to Ibn al-Haitham, though, the Chinese philosopher Mozi had already begun developing a variety of a pinhole camera in the fourth century BC. Later in that same century, both Aristotle and Euclid remarked on the placement of light when projected through pinholes. What is more, the Arab mathematician Abu Yusuf Ya‘qub Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi became the first to project images with an early type of camera obscura in the ninth century. As a result, although Ibn al-Haitham is often credited with the creation of the camera obscura, he is also recorded as having said that he did not invent it.



Please help by explaining more.



TheGraceful with all sincerity you should be absolutely careful how some terms like fairness affects the passage these are subjective based on people for example a i phone might be great for one however this may not be the case for other for example if a person is one a budget the nord 100 would be better
Apologizing for the vague example however my main point being that when you look at terms that exemplies something you should always put forward your skeptism first , even though there is no question about your dedication you should keep these subtle things in mind to ace the Gmat it'a a hard fought mind game
Senior Manager
Senior Manager
Joined: 10 Apr 2018
Posts: 340
Own Kudos [?]: 201 [0]
Given Kudos: 217
Concentration: Leadership, Strategy
GMAT 1: 600 Q44 V28
GPA: 3.56
WE:Engineering (Computer Software)
Send PM
Re: It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera de [#permalink]
Crytiocanalyst wrote:

TheGraceful with all sincerity you should be absolutely careful how some terms like fairness affects the passage these are subjective based on people for example a i phone might be great for one however this may not be the case for other for example if a person is one a budget the nord 100 would be better
Apologizing for the vague example however my main point being that when you look at terms that exemplies something you should always put forward your skeptism first , even though there is no question about your dedication you should keep these subtle things in mind to ace the Gmat it'a a hard fought mind game


Yes, I got the point and intent.
Thanks.
Manager
Manager
Joined: 09 Aug 2020
Posts: 224
Own Kudos [?]: 81 [0]
Given Kudos: 163
Location: India
Schools: IIMA PGPX'23
GMAT 1: 710 Q48 V39 (Online)
Send PM
Re: It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera de [#permalink]
Crytiocanalyst wrote:
TheGraceful wrote:
Hi Bunuel,
Although its official explanation that says B is the correct answer choice, I am NOT convinced and am doubtful about the explanation.

Since I agree with explanations for answer choices A, C and E, I will discuss only about B and D here.

(B) Ibn al-Haitham’s development of the camera obscura in the eleventh century was the result of discoveries in previous centuries that contributed to his research.
==> This can NOT be inferred from the para/passage. Although some work was made on presursor of camera, but it can NOT be said that contributed to Ibn al-Haitham's work. Ibn al-Haitham independently discovered the thing.
Let's have a look at para (highlighted)


Bunuel wrote:
It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera derives from the camera obscura, usually credited to the Arab scientist Abu Ali Al-Hasan Ibn al-Haitham in the eleventh century. Working in an early version of a dark room, Ibn al-Haitham studied the movement of light and discovered that he could reproduce images by reflecting light through pinholes. Prior to Ibn al-Haitham, though, the Chinese philosopher Mozi had already begun developing a variety of a pinhole camera in the fourth century BC. Later in that same century, both Aristotle and Euclid remarked on the placement of light when projected through pinholes. What is more, the Arab mathematician Abu Yusuf Ya‘qub Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi became the first to project images with an early type of camera obscura in the ninth century. As a result, although Ibn al-Haitham is often credited with the creation of the camera obscura, he is also recorded as having said that he did not invent it.

As for his saying of he did NOT invent it, doesn't concretely mean his predecessors did it, he could have wanted to share the credit with any of his assistant, friend, family member, pet that made.



(D) Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi is unfairly overlooked as the real inventor of the camera obscura.
Since other options are eliminated this becomes our answer. Moreover, look at the passage (highlited the things) that supports this option.
Bunuel wrote:
It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera derives from the camera obscura, usually credited to the Arab scientist Abu Ali Al-Hasan Ibn al-Haitham in the eleventh century. Working in an early version of a dark room, Ibn al-Haitham studied the movement of light and discovered that he could reproduce images by reflecting light through pinholes. Prior to Ibn al-Haitham, though, the Chinese philosopher Mozi had already begun developing a variety of a pinhole camera in the fourth century BC. Later in that same century, both Aristotle and Euclid remarked on the placement of light when projected through pinholes. What is more, the Arab mathematician Abu Yusuf Ya‘qub Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi became the first to project images with an early type of camera obscura in the ninth century. As a result, although Ibn al-Haitham is often credited with the creation of the camera obscura, he is also recorded as having said that he did not invent it.



Please help by explaining more.



TheGraceful with all sincerity you should be absolutely careful how some terms like fairness affects the passage these are subjective based on people for example a i phone might be great for one however this may not be the case for other for example if a person is one a budget the nord 100 would be better
Apologizing for the vague example however my main point being that when you look at terms that exemplies something you should always put forward your skeptism first , even though there is no question about your dedication you should keep these subtle things in mind to ace the Gmat it'a a hard fought mind game


Hi Crytiocanalyst,

Instead of writing on the "subjectivity" of the arqgument/options, it would have been highly helpful if you could have helped us in showing from where option B can be inferred from the passage.

I stand by TheGraceful on this one. Ibn al-Haitham could have developed tha camera independently as well.

To show that his work was a result of discoveries in previous centuries that contributed to his research, we have to signify somehow that Ibn al-Haitham somehow read their works or interacted with them on this matter.

Please make us understand your thought process on this one. :)
Director
Director
Joined: 16 Jun 2021
Posts: 976
Own Kudos [?]: 187 [0]
Given Kudos: 309
Send PM
It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera de [#permalink]
Hi Crytiocanalyst,

Instead of writing on the "subjectivity" of the arqgument/options, it would have been highly helpful if you could have helped us in showing from where option B can be inferred from the passage.

I stand by TheGraceful on this one. Ibn al-Haitham could have developed tha camera independently as well.

To show that his work was a result of discoveries in previous centuries that contributed to his research, we have to signify somehow that Ibn al-Haitham somehow read their works or interacted with them on this matter.

Please make us understand your thought process on this one. :)




It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera derives from the camera obscura, usually credited to the Arab scientist Abu Ali Al-Hasan Ibn al-Haitham in the eleventh century. Working in an early version of a dark room, Ibn al-Haitham studied the movement of light and discovered that he could reproduce images by reflecting light through pinholes. Prior to Ibn al-Haitham, though, the Chinese philosopher Mozi had already begun developing a variety of a
pinhole camera in the fourth century BC
. Later in that same century, both Aristotle and Euclid remarked on the placement of light when projected through pinholes. What is more, the Arab mathematician Abu Yusuf Ya‘qub Ibn Ishaq al-Kindi became the first to project images with an early type of camera obscura in the ninth century. As a result, although Ibn al-Haitham is often credited with the creation of the camera obscura, he is also recorded as having said that he did not invent it.



These are the two instances that made me conclude that Ibn didn't invent the camera himself but was a result of combined effort of several others like Mozi , Arab mathematicians , Aristole and Euclid they all independently developed so you could question was it not unfair to give credit to Ibn what if there was not a system in the earlier period where there was mo system where minor however important discoveries were not appreciated or rather recognised since all other inventors were dead and it was onlt Ibn was to recognise their importance of all the invention and reunite them then IBn had done the right thing and not unfairly overlooked

Therefore IMO B hope it clarifies
GMAT Club Bot
It is believed that the earliest precursor to the modern-day camera de [#permalink]
Moderators:
GMAT Club Verbal Expert
6989 posts
GMAT Club Verbal Expert
236 posts
CR Forum Moderator
824 posts