parkhydel
Linguist: Plosives and fricatives are two classes of consonants. A "voicing contrast" is a distinction between two consonants that are identical except that one is voiced and the other is unvoiced. In language family X, languages with voicing contrasts in their fricatives always have voicing contrasts in their plosives. This means that in that family, any given language has a voicing contrast in its fricatives __________ it has a voicing contrast in its plosives. In other words, a given language in that family lacks any voicing contrasts in its plosives __________ it lacks any such contrasts in its fricatives.
Select for
First blank the word or phrase that most logically completes the statement with the first blank. And select for
Second blank the word or phrase that most logically completes the statement with the second blank. Make only two selections, one in each column.
Ignoring the initial distractions, and moving to the core region.
“
In language family X, languages with voicing contrasts in their fricatives always have voicing contrasts in their plosives”.
Let’s take the fricatives and plosives as f and p respectively.
IF
vc(f) is yes, then vc(p) is a yes. what, vc(f) is NOT YES - No, then the outcome of vc(p) is 2 ways : can be yes. OR can be no.
Converting the previous inference to a table.
If vc(f) ✅ ———> then vc(p) is ✅.
vc(f) ❌ —————> vc(p) is ✅ OR
vc(f) ❌—————> vc(p) is ❌.
Now to the question.
any given language has a voicing contrast in its fricatives __________ it has a voicing contrast in its plosives. vc(f) is ✅ when vc(p) is also ✅. So,
ONLY IF
Now, to the next blank space,
In other words, a given language in that family lacks any voicing contrasts in its plosives __________ it lacks any such contrasts in its fricatives.
vc(p) ❌ occurs
ONLY IF vc(f) ❌.