Michael KC Chen
Which of the following most logically completes the argument ?
Lyme disease is caused by a bacterium transmitted to people by deer ticks. Deer ticks are almost never born infected with the bacterium, but they can pick it up from feeding on an infected host in any of the tick's three successive stage of development: larva, nymph, adult. Once infected, a tick remains infected through any subsequent developmental stages, but since a tick feeds on only one host in each stage, it follows that ______________
A. People can be infected only by being bitten by a tick that is either in larval stage or in the nymph stage
B. People cannot be infected by a tick that picked up the Lyme disease bacterium in the adult stage
C. It is not possible for a person to be infected by a tick that is in the nymph stage or by a tick that was infected with the bacterium while in the nymph stage
D. People infected with the Lyme disease bacterium cannot transmit bacterium to adult deer ticks
E. Only deer ticks that are adults can transmit the Lyme disease bacterium to people
"Lyme disease" Strengthen Question"Lyme disease" Evaluate Argument QuestionDoes anyone know how to draw the logical picture of this question ?
I went with POE but still got this question incorrect ....
A/E are out for sure....
have no idea about the rest 3 ....
Thanks ...
This is an inference kind of question. We need to find what we can conclude from the given premises.
Premises:Lyme disease is caused by a bacterium transmitted to people by deer ticks.
Deer ticks pick up bacterium from feeding on an infected host in any of the tick's three successive stage of development: larva, nymph, adult.
Once infected, a tick remains infected through any subsequent developmental stages,
a tick feeds on only one host in each stage
Conclusion: _____________________
The hint is given in what is immediately before the black: "Once infected, a tick remains infected through any subsequent developmental stages, but since a tick feeds on only one host in each stage, it follows that ______________
A. People can be infected only by being bitten by a tick that is either in larval stage or in the nymph stageNothing in the passage suggests that people cannot be bitten in the tick's adult stage.
B. People cannot be infected by a tick that picked up the Lyme disease bacterium in the adult stageIf it feeds on only one host per stage and if it picked up the bacterium in the adult stage from the infected host, then people will not be infected by it because it has already been fed in the adult stage (it feeds on only one host per stage). So this works.
C. It is not possible for a person to be infected by a tick that is in the nymph stage or by a tick that was infected with the bacterium while in the nymph stageAgain no such information abotu nymph stage.
D. People infected with the Lyme disease bacterium cannot transmit bacterium to adult deer ticksNo info on whether people can infect adult deer ticks with the bacterium.
E. Only deer ticks that are adults can transmit the Lyme disease bacterium to peopleNo such info given.
Answer (B)