I'm not that big an expert but in these schools, I'm seeing the similar brand power- in Midwest.
I think Notre Dame and Kelley are both consistent schools and have a good placement in Consulting and Tech, Notredame has a little edge on consulting given that it's very close to Chicago. (Heard there's even a direct metro)
That said, I would also suggest you do the opportunity cost analysis. The post-MBA salaries, years to payback, not to forget Covid related recession downturn may cause companies to pay less initially.
I would go with the money if the difference is that huge when it comes to it. (If everything else is the same- Even in USA brand power beyond top 15 is regional- east, west, Midwest, south)
Posted from my mobile device