Hi sasha13,For a "can be supported" question, the trick is to treat it almost like a mini-inference question: the right answer must be something the text
directly backs up, not something that merely sounds reasonable or that only one of the two studies claims. Let me walk you through how B falls right out of the passage.
Where B comes fromLook at this line in the second paragraph (the PNAS study):
"...males balanced the need to spread their gene pool against the need to protect their young from being killed."If two needs have to be
balanced against each other, that means they can pull in
opposite directions - you can't always maximize both at once. That is exactly what B says:
-
Spreading the gene pool = mating with as many females as possible.
-
Protecting the young = staying with one female.
The passage even sets this up in the first paragraph: "Mating with one female at a time
lowers a male's chances of producing as many offspring as possible." So the two goals
conflict - they can be contradicting priorities. That's all B claims, and the text supports it plainly.
Why the others fail-
A - Big brains are tied only to
humans needing longer nurturing. The passage never says bigger-brained species are generally more monogamous. Out of scope.
-
C - This is Opie's claim from
one study, and the Science study found
no correlation. The passage leaves it disputed, so it isn't "supported."
-
D - Reversed. It's the
monogamous mammals' females who are intolerant of other females; ungulates are
rarely monogamous.
-
E - Contradicted. The whole passage presents an
ongoing debate ("a fascinating fight"), so the reasons are
not well understood.
Notice the pattern: the four wrong answers are either
reversed (D),
too strong / contradicted (C, E), or
out of scope (A). B is the only one that just restates what the text says. That's your target on every "supported" question.
Answer: Bsasha13
1. Which one of the following can be supported by the information given in the passage?
A. Species with bigger brains are more likely to be monogamous.
B. Spreading the gene pool and protecting the young can be contradicting priorities.
C. Infanticide is the driver of monogamy in mammals.
D. Ungulate females are intolerant of other females.
E. Reasons behind monogamy in mammals are well understood.
HOW TO SOLVE QUESTION 1 AND WHY IS IT OPTION B?