The real question you guys should be asking yourself is:
What companies recruit at my school?
Because you could go to Genius University, #1 ranked in the entire Milky Way Galaxy...but if the firm you want to get into doesn't recruit there, you're out of luck.
If I were you guys, I would ditch the PAR rankings. Screw that. It's nice to look at. It's nice to brag about after you got your diploma. But at the end of the day, what I would do is look for the LARGEST schools within a 2-4 hour radius of the city you want to work in. From there, I would send an email to the accounting program and ask if you can have a list of all of the employers that registered for their business school career fair in the Fall. Also, obtain a list of all of the firms that held interviews on-campus. Finally, ask for the email of one of the students.
Forward the two lists to the student and ask if they seem to coincide with that student's experiences (i.e. are the lists real, or BS?).
Then, choose the school with the larger # of firms that you're interested in.
Nobody cares if you got your MACC from USC or Texas. Just like, once you start working, nobody cares whether you had an intership. The only thing that matters is your performance on the job - if you are impressing your senior and manager, it will be because of your ability and accounting knowledge, not because you went to a good school.
Finally, the reason I suggest going to a large school is simple. The recruiting game is total BS. Really, it is. It's not so much about finding the best students as it is about managers/partners hooking kids up from their alma maters. If you are in an interview with a manager or a partner from the school you went to - your interview has a much better chance of going well. You will already have things in common. You will already know what your interviewer will want to talk about - the school's football team, what it was like when he went there, the professors, etc. So, if you go to a large school you have tons of alumni that are entering the workforce every year, and therefore tons of people who it will be easier to succeed in an interview with.
And you should look for schools near where you want to work because, unless you already have a job lined up, you aren't going to have the balls to ask for them to send you half way across the country. It's asking a lot of the recruiter. More than likely, it wont happen and they wont invite you for an office visit.