Hi mbasync,
Thanks for your question and congratulations on your two acceptances! I find these are very personal decisions so I'm not sure how much impact my advice may have, to be honest, but here is my take on some of the factors you should be considering...
-Career prospects: Take a look at the employment reports from both schools and see where most alumni end up. How do recent grads fare in your target industry? Are there any significant differences in terms of locations, companies that recruit there, or starting salaries?
-Curriculum: Are classes taught by lecture, case study or more hands-on and which style fits best with how you learn?
-Location: NYC and Oklahoma are very different in terms of what they have to offer and what it's like to live there - which environment appeals to you more?
-Overall reputation: of the university and the business school, especially in your field of interest
-Alumni network: both size of network and where they are located
-General fit: have you talked to current students and alumni to see what they like best about each program?
I know it's a tough call and may depend on personal things like finances and family too so definitely make sure you are weighing all of these factors. Good luck with the decision and let us know if we can help.