bb
Hi. Congrats on your admits and Welcome to GMAT Club!
The answer really depends on what/how you are planning to use the Degree. If you are planning to grow within your current company, then there is a strong case for cost/logistics. At the same time if you are thinking of networking and leveraging NYU for a potential job/career shift, then Villanova which is not ranked by US news would be a far cry of a comparison vs. NYU.
Think about it - playing Satruday basketball on your local playground vs. going into the city to play with Nets.... though they may be headed to a playground too but you get the idea. NYU is a stronger program, more selective, which means it attracts stronger and more serious students, better faculty, and builds a sense of exclusivity which creates camaraderie among those who were able to be a part of the experience. That also results into a stronger alum network, better networking opportunities, etc.
P.S. Disclaimer, I really don't know much about Villanova. It may be an amazing program, we just have not had anyone post much about it.
Thanks for the detailed response - I really appreciate it! I would love to grow within my current company, but at the same time no one knows where they'll end up. I've always tried to go above and beyond my whole life and really feel like having an NYU education and brand appeal on my resume would be great and a personal goal, but all other signs regarding logistics and financing point to Villanova. I need to keep thinking about it, but thanks!