We've been told that the day trader makes a profit of $250 after trading 50 stocks of a particular company.
This means that the stock he bought had a change of 250/50 = $5 from 9 AM to 13:00.
So we are looking for a stock that had gone up by $5 in that time frame. Note that the chart goes beyond 13:00.

In this time from 9 to 13:00 the following price changes occurred. Note that we should check all of them to be safe. You do not need a calculator but can quickly note the differences and which one will be equal to 5.
Company A goes 55 -> 65, i.e. a change of +10
Company B goes 20 -> 30, i.e a change of +10
Company C goes 105 -> 110. i.e. a Change of +5
CORRECTCompany D goes 65 -> 50, i.e a change of -15
The Answer is Company C. In the second part, we've been asked how much the stock has changed by closing time at 16:00. This is a trap in case you look at 13:00 instead of 16:00.
Therefore, at 16:00, Stock C is at $115, i.e. the change is 115-105 = +$10.
Attachment:
GMAT-Club-Forum-7h1x62tx.png [ 91.48 KiB | Viewed 4426 times ]