13. Must or Could be True13.1. If a^3 > b^6 > c^9, which of the following orderings of a, b, and c could be true?I. a > b > c
II. c > b > a
III. a > c > b
A. I only
B. I and II only
C. I and III only
D. II and III only
E. I, II, and III
First, notice that the question asks
which of the following could be true, not
which of the following must be true.
In
must be true questions, the correct statement must hold for every valid set of numbers. So, if you can find even one valid example in which a statement fails, that statement cannot be correct. This means the plug-in method is useful for eliminating choices, but it is not enough by itself to prove that a statement must be true.
Could be true questions work differently. Here, a statement is correct if there exists at least one valid set of numbers for which it holds. So, once you find one valid example that satisfies both the given condition and the statement, you have proved that the statement could be true.
Because this is a could be true question, it is enough to find one valid example for a statement to show that it could be true.
Also, since taking cube roots preserves the order of an inequality, we can simplify
a^3 > b^6 > c^9
to
a > b^2 > c^3
which is much easier to work with.
I. a > b > c
This statement presents the same order as the variables in the given inequality, which means that when we square b and cube c, the order can still remain consistent. To check whether this could be true, try a small positive value for c, a somewhat larger positive value for b, and a large positive value for a.
For example, let a = 10, b = 2, and c = 1. Then:
a > b^2 > c^3
10 > 2^2 > 1^3
So statement I could be true.
II. c > b > a
If we want c to be greater than b, but still want b^2 > c^3, then positive fractions less than 1 are a good choice, because raising such numbers to positive integer powers makes them smaller.
Take c = 1/2 and b = 2/5. Then c > b, and (b^2 = 4/25) > (c^3 = 1/8).
Now choose a number smaller than b = 2/5 but greater than b^2 = 4/25. Let a = 1/4.
Then:
(c = 1/2) > (b = 2/5) > (a = 1/4)
and
(a = 1/4) > (b^2 = 4/25) > (c^3 = 1/8)
So statement II could be true.
III. a > c > b
Here it is helpful to make b negative. That way b can be smaller than c, but b^2, which becomes positive, can still be large.
Take b = -2 and c = 1. Then (b^2 = 4) > (c^3 = 1)
Now choose a = 5. Then
(a = 5) > (c = 1) > (b = -2)
and
(a = 5) > (b^2 = 4) > (c^3 = 1)
So statement III could be true.
Answer: E.
TakeawayIt is important to know the difference between
must be true questions and
could be true questions, because the strategy is different. In a must be true question, you are testing whether a statement works in every valid case, so one counterexample is enough to eliminate it. In a could be true question, one valid example is enough to confirm it. It is also important to be comfortable with how numbers behave when raised to powers, since powers can change the relative size of numbers, especially when comparing positive integers, fractions between 0 and 1, 0, and negative numbers.
What This Question TestsThis question tests could be true reasoning, together with number behavior under exponents and inequality number sense. It also tests whether you can choose efficient values and use them correctly to check which orderings are possible under the given condition.