natuago91
Say in additional to the deposit you didn’t find out from your waitlist school until July and you had already put in a deposit for your new apartment. Now we’re talking about deposit plus backing out of an apartment contract you haven’t even lived in (not sure how much the penalty would be 1-2 month rent?) or say if you get in even later- August and you’re ready to move into the new apartment when your top choice lets you know- what would you do? Go to top choice and scramble to find a place to live at the last minute?
I think it depends

How much is that top choice school worth to you? Are you willing to pay that extra 5k for it? If so, yes - go for the top choice. If you aren't, and you think it's really a wash between the school you were admitted to and the top choice, then perhaps it's not worth it. I think the scenario you described is really a personal choice!