The Grand Canyon,
which was previously thought to have been carved out by the Colorado River, was eroded away by a lava flow, according to a newer theory, took on its current form at an earlier date 6 to 7 million years ago.
A. which was previously thought to have been carved out by the Colorado River, was eroded away by a lava flow, according to a newer theory, --Th
is is a single subject- double verbing without proper conjugation The are two verbs for the subject grand Canyon namely 'was eroded' and 'took' with just a comma in between. B. previously thought to have been carved out by the Colorado River eroded away by a lava flow, according to a newer theory, and
--The first part of the sentence is a fragment without a verb. Eroded in the context is a past participle. C. previously thought to have been carved out by the Colorado River, was eroded away by a lava flow, according to a newer theory,---
All the above problems have been solved. Correct choice. D. previously thought to have been carved out by the Colorado River, according to a newer theory, it eroded away by a lava flow and---
It is not clear what the pronoun 'it' refers to. It could be the Canyon or the River. In addition, this is the correct context for using a passive voice as 'was eroded.' E. previously thought to have been carved out by the Colorado River, according to a newer theory, which was eroded away by a lava flow and--
which seems to refer to the theory as if the theory was eroded.