The impact of the 1930s crisis on the different regions of Country X varied depending on the relationship of each region's economy to the international marketplace, with region A most drastically affected. Interestingly, demand in foreign markets for Region A's tropical crops was only slightly affected by the drop in income levels after 1929; the same was true of foreign demand for the temperate-zone basic foodstuffs produced by Region B. However, Region B was better able to survive the crisis, largely avoiding the economic damage suffered by Region A's economy.

Which one of the following provides the most reasonable explanation for the fact that Region A's economy was more drastically effected by the slight decrease in demand than was Region B's?


(A) Tropical crops like those produced by Region A usually command higher prices on the world market than do basic foodstuffs like those produced by Region B.

(B) Region B's economy was dependent on annual crops, the supply of which is easily adjusted because the plants are renewed each year, in contrast to the perennial crops grown in Region A.

(C) Because tropical goods are generally bought by more affluent consumers, demand for these products rarely declines even when overall income levels drop.

(D) The temperate-zone basic foodstuffs produced in Region B directly competed with similar crops produced by the countries that imported Region B's goods.

(E) Because Region B's economy was dependent on the export of basic foodstuffs, there was only a slight decline in demand for its goods even after income levels dropped.
_________________

Premise:

The impact of the 1930s crisis on the different regions of Country X varied depending on the relationship of each region's economy to the international marketplace
International Crisis affected A's Economy affected.
But demand for A`s tropical crops was only slightly affected .The same was true of foreign demand for the Region B`s Stuff. (A's,B's - Crops Demand was want not affected)
However, Region B was better able to survive the crisis, largely avoiding the economic damage suffered by Region A's economy.


I would like Classify these Kind of questions as "Why" Questions:

In these Kind of Question we Generally find the Premise explaining "Un Common Result" and asking to provide an answer why is that "Un Common Result" Happening.

In this Case For Example : Its Trying to ask why "Region B`s Economy was better able to survive the crisis whereas Region A's economy was not[Even Though both the A`s & B's Products Market Value is not reduced Drastically]"

Definitely any Option That tries to Provide some difference between A's & B`s Product or A's & B`s Economy should be a Convincing Answer.[Please keep in mind these Kind of PreThinking is necessary]

A) Tropical crops like those produced by Region A usually command higher prices on the world market than do basic foodstuffs like those produced by Region B.

This Cannot be the Answer : Lets Suppose Assume the Value is 10x,x respectively.The Market Value Reduces to 9.9x,0.9x : So what? Does this provide Why A had a serious Economy Crisis NO

B) Region B's economy was dependent on annual crops, the supply of which is easily adjusted because the plants are renewed each year, in contrast to the perennial crops grown in Region A.

This Could be the Answer : It shows a difference between how Country A,Country B Depend on the Market Place Price of their Crops. Country B has a Plan to recover in Low market value Situation whereas A doesn't.


C) Because tropical goods are generally bought by more affluent consumers, demand for these products rarely declines even when overall income levels drop.

This Cannot be the Answer : Doesn't Explain the Difference Between A & B

D) The temperate-zone basic foodstuffs produced in Region B directly competed with similar crops produced by the countries that imported Region B's goods.

This Cannot be the Answer : Doesn't Explain the Difference Between A & B

E) Because Region B's economy was dependent on the export of basic foodstuffs, there was only a slight decline in demand for its goods even after income levels dropped.

This Cannot be the Answer: Doesnt Explain the Difference Between A & B

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________