The number of deer living in North America has increased dramatically since the 1960s even though hunters kill no fewer deer today. Moreover, the number of natural predators of deer, such as wolves, is on the rise, and suburbs increasingly encroach on deer habitats.
Which one of the following, if true, would most help to explain the apparent discrepancy described above?The puzzle is that the deer population has increased dramatically even though hunting has not decreased, predators have increased, and habitat has been reduced.
The best explanation should identify another factor that could have improved deer survival or reproduction
enough to outweigh these negative pressures.
(A) Pesticides that adversely affected most wildlife living in North America have been banned since the 1970s.
Correct. “Since the 1960s” refers to the entire period beginning in the 1960s and continuing afterward. If harmful pesticides were banned in the 1970s, an important factor limiting deer survival or reproduction was removed for much of that period. This could have outweighed the effects of hunting, predators, and habitat loss and helped produce the dramatic population increase.
(B) Recently, attempts have been made in various parts of North America to protect deer habitats from suburban development.
Incorrect. The passage says suburban development has continued to reduce deer habitat. Protecting some habitat merely means that the habitat loss may have been less severe than it otherwise would have been. That does not explain why the deer population increased dramatically.
(C) The number of deer hunters in North America has decreased since the 1960s.
Incorrect. The passage already tells us that hunters kill no fewer deer today. So fewer hunters would simply mean that the remaining hunters kill more deer on average. It does not explain the population increase.
(D) Much of the increase in the population of wolves is due to wolves born in captivity and released into the wild.
Incorrect. Regardless of where the additional wolves came from, there are still more wolves in the wild that can prey on deer. This does not explain the increase in deer.
(E) The greater the number of deer, the more likely they are to be afflicted with problems such as famine and disease.
Incorrect. This gives another factor that should limit deer population growth, making the discrepancy harder rather than easier to explain.
Answer: (A)