OFFICIAL EXPLANATIONProject SC Butler: Sentence Correction (SC2)
THE PROMPTQuote:
The private lending sector has $8 billion in student loans that are in default or at such serious risk to default that it does not expect payments when it is due and has consequently tightened credit standards for new student loans.
• MAIN ISSUE TESTED: PRONOUNS
In particular, this question tests the usage of two pronouns that refer to
different antecedents.
As long as there is only one logical antecedent to which a pronoun refers, the pronoun is acceptable—even if more than one pronoun exists.
→ Correct:
Timothy bought Miranda a present and gave it to her when she got home from work. This sentence is modeled on an official question that you can find
here.
The
private lending sector is a singular noun and takes the singular pronoun
it.
The noun
payments is plural and requires the plural pronoun
them.
THE OPTIONSQuote:
A) that it does not expect payments when it is
• noun/pronoun disagreement
→ the singular pronoun
it does not agree with the plural antecedent
paymentsELIMINATE A
Quote:
B) that payments will not be expected to be paid when
• strange phrasing and out-of-context passive voice construction
Hmm.
→ The passive voice in this context creates a situation in which we are not completely sure who does not expect payments to be made.
→ The phrase
will not be expected to be paid is a little weird.
When we describe a general state of unchanging affairs, we use simple present tense, not future tense.
KEEP, but look for a better answer
Quote:
C) that it does not expect payments to be made when they are
• this option seems grammatical
→ the singular pronoun
it correctly refers to its singular antecedent
the private lending sector→ the plural
they correctly refers to its plural antecedent,
payments• this option is better than option B, so ELIMINATE B, and
KEEP
Quote:
D) that payments are not expected to be paid when they are going to be
•
payments and
to be paid are redundant (if you have a hard time deciding, compare to option C, which is better)
• as is the case in option B, the future tense (are going to be) creates a messy sentence.
→ compare to option C, in which simple present tense is used effectively to describe a general and unchanging state of affairs
ELIMINATE D
Quote:
E) that they do not expect payments when it is
• the plural pronoun
they does not agree with the logical antecedent
the private lending sectors• the singular pronoun
it does not agree with the plural antecedent
paymentsELIMINATE E
The correct answer is C.NOTESIf you cannot decide whether an option contains clear error within 5-10 seconds of having read the option,
keep it and move on.As you get better at SC, force yourself to make that call within 3-5 seconds of having read the option.
In option B, for example, something is wrong, but it is not easy to articulate what that something is.
Keep such options tentatively.
When we read option C, which is better than option B, we can eliminate B.
COMMENTSI am typing quickly to finish while both troublesome electricity and internet are working properly, so these answers may sound a bit abrupt.
These answers are range from very good to outstanding.
petrichor , I am bumping you to Best Community Reply.
Nice work, everyone.