alax123
can you please explain why option A is correct and not option E? Thanks in advance!
sorry!! im referring to question 1!
Ishatv
hey, could you explain why E is wrong and A is correct in q1.
After reading the passage twice I am going with the OA yet i believe the OA is not the best answer but only better among the available options. This make the question debatable.
It is clear that answer
options (B), (C), and
(D) are out of the race and only
(A) and
(E) are contenders. Answer
option (E) is based on the following text.
But in the fifth century Rome, oppressed on every side by enemies, and distracted with the vastness of her conquests, which she was no longer able to maintain, recalled her legions from Britain; and the Romanized Britons being left without protection, and having, during their subjection to the Romans, lost their ancient valor and love of liberty, in a short time fell a prey to the Northern Barbarians; in their extremity they called over the Saxons to assist them, when the latter perceiving their defenseless condition, turned round upon them, and made an easy conquest of this country.
But after reading so much text from the passage we still cannot infer the intentions of
The Northern Barbarians. It may be correct that the Northern Barbarians took the advantage of Rome’s exit from Britain in order to conquer the region but we cannot guarantee with the help of the passage.
On the other hand answer
option (A) is based on the passage overall and it presents the bigger picture of the passage. Below is the Official Explanation.
Official Explanation
1. Based on the passage, the author would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements about Roman Britain?
Explanation
A is the best answer. This question requires some inferring as well as close rereading. C, D, and E are all answer choices that take some element of the passage and present it in hopes that you’ll remember the phrase it contains and choose it. But all present the information from the text incorrectly, which is why it’s important to double-check. B is a bit trickier, as it makes a broader statement that can’t be checked by looking at the passage’s facts. However, it is quite broad and you know that the GMAT rewards careful choices, not broad inferences. That makes A the best choice.
Answer: A