Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be li

Question

Competition Mode Question

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be light  compared to the days of the early West when  cattle rustlers were hanged from the nearest tree.

(A) compared to the days of the early West when
(B) compared with those in the days of the early West in which
(C) compared with those in the days of the early West when
(D) in comparison with them of the early Western days when
(E) in comparison to the days of the early West in which

Leadership · Answer

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be light  compared to the days of the early West when  cattle rustlers were hanged from the nearest tree.

We can get the first split by 'When' vs. 'in Which'. We are dealing with the time (days), so WHEN is correct. We can remove B and E and left with A, C, D.
 
(A)  compared to  the days of the early West when  - 'should be 'compared with' for similar entities' 
(B) compared with those in the days of the early West  in which   - 'in which' is wrong 
(C) compared with those in the days of the early West when  - Correct 
(D) in comparison with  them   of the early Western days when  - easy out for using 'them' 
(E) in comparison to the days of the early West  in which   - 'in which' is wrong

Raxit85 · Answer

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be light compared to the days of the early West when cattle rustlers were hanged from the nearest tree.

(A) compared to the days of the early West when - sentences compared with the days. So, incorrect
(B) compared with those in the days of the early West in which - incorrect usage of in which. 
(C) compared with those in the days of the early West when - sentences compared with sentences and conveys the proper meaning. Correct
(D) in comparison with them of the early Western days when - incorrect usage of in comparison with and them in the sentence.
(E) in comparison to the days of the early West in which - Incorrect usage of in comparison and in which. Incorrect.

Imo. C

Archit3110 · Answer

IMO C: compared with those in the days of the early West when

compared with those is correct comparision than compared to the days

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be light  compared to the days of the early West when  cattle rustlers were hanged from the nearest tree.

(A) compared to the days of the early West when
(B) compared with those in the days of the early West in which
(C) compared with those in the days of the early West when
(D) in comparison with them of the early Western days when
(E) in comparison to the days of the early West in which

daagh · Answer

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be light  compared to the days of the early West when  cattle rustlers were hanged from the nearest tree.

T he comparison is between the sentences today with those sentences of the early West. The plural demonstrative pronoun 'those in' vouches for that.

(A) compared to the days of the early West when --  faulty comparison of sentences with the days  
(B) compared with those in the days of the early West in which --  'in which' is incorrect. The adverb 'when' is required to refer to the time. 
 
(C) Compared with those in the days of the early West when --  The best choice.  
(D) in comparison with them of the early Western days when--  The subject sentences requires another subject pronoun namely 'those" the object pronoun 'them' is wro ng. 
(E) In comparison to the days of the early West in which - - 1.Comparison to the days is wrong, 2. "In which" is wrong 
C is the correct answer

madgmat2019 · Answer

(A)  compared to the days  of the early West when
(B) compared with those in the days of the early West  in which 
 (C) compared with those in the days of the early West when 
(D)  in comparison with  them of the early Western days when
(E)  in comparison to  the days of the early West  in which

OA:C

PTD1995 · Answer

Option C

A)  INCORRECT!  Wrong comparison between sentences and the days.
B)  INCORRECT!  Since we are talking about days, the use of "in which" can be improved.
C)  CORRECT! 
D)  INCORRECT!  The use of "them" leads to some ambiguity.
E)  INCORRECT!  Same as A)

eakabuah · Answer

C is the right answer in my view.

In this sentence, a comparison is made between sentences of convicted rustlers today and sentences of rustlers in the days of the early west. We must ensure the items being compared are parallel.

In A, the comparison is between sentences of convicted rustlers today and the days of the early West. This is an illogical, non-parallel comparison. The same illogical comparison in A is repeated in E as well. Eliminate A and E based on this.
A demonstrative pronoun  those  rather than the object pronoun  them  is needed here to point back to sentences. We can eliminate D based on this.
Between B and C, I opt for C over B because when is used to modify today in the non-underlined portion of the sentence. The use of when suggests a specific point in time that is today. Hence, to maintain parallelism between the timeframes, I opt for C because C also use when to modify the days of the early west.

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be light compared to the days of the early West when cattle rustlers were hanged from the nearest tree.

(A)  compared to   the days of the early West  when
(B)  compared with    those   in the days of the early West  in which 
(C)  compared with    those   in the days of the early West when
(D)  in comparison  with  them  of the early Western days when
(E)  in comparison  to  the days of the early West  in which

exc4libur · Answer

NOTES: comparison between "sentences x sentences"; "when" is used to describe time.

Ans (C)

unraveled · Answer

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be light  compared to the days of the early West when  cattle rustlers were hanged from the nearest tree.

(A) compared to the days of the early West when - WRONG. wrong comparison of 'sentences' and 'days'.
(B) compared with those in the days of the early West in which - WRONG. 'in which' is wrong usage for timeline.
(C) compared with those in the days of the early West when - CORRECT. 'Those' is correctly compared to 'sentences' and 'when' is also correctly used.
(D) in comparison with them of the early Western days when - WRONG. 'them of' is wrong.
(E) in comparison to the days of the early West in which - WRONG. wrong comparison.

IMO Answer C.

chaitralirr · Answer

IMOC

Compared with those correctly refers to sentences. the sentence also maintains parallelism while comparing the days of rustlers to the cattle rustlers were convicted.

Posted from my mobile device

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be li

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

Today, even when rustlers are convicted, their sentences tend to be li

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards