The making of classifications by literary historians can be a somewhat

Question

The making of classifications by literary historians can be a somewhat risky enterprise. When Black poets are discussed separately as a group, for instance, the extent to which their work reflects the development of poetry in general should not be forgotten, or a distortion of literary history may result. This caution is particularly relevant in an assessment of the differences between Black poets at the turn of the century (1900-1909) and those of the generation of the 1920’s. These differences include the bolder and more forthright speech of the later generation and its technical inventiveness. It should be remembered, though, that comparable differences also existed for similar generations of White poets.

When poets of the 1910’s and 1920’s are considered together, however, the distinctions that literary historians might make between “conservative” and “experimental” would be of  little significance  in a discussion of Black poets, although these remain helpful classifications for White poets of these decades. Certainly differences can be noted between “conservative” Black poets such as Counter Cullen and Claude McKay and “experimental” ones such as Jean Toomer and Langston Hughes. But Black poets were not battling over old or new styles; rather, one accomplished Black poet was ready to welcome another, whatever his or her style, for what mattered was racial pride.

However, in the 1920’s Black poets did debate whether they should deal with specifically racial subjects. They asked whether they should only write about Black experience for a Black audience or whether such demands were restrictive. It may be said, though, that virtually all these poets wrote their best poems when they spoke out of racial feeling, race being, as James Weldon Johnson rightly put it, “perforce the thing the Negro poet knows best.”

At the turn of the century, by contrast, most Black poets generally wrote in the conventional manner of the age and expressed noble, if vague, emotions in their poetry. These poets were not unusually gifted, though Roscoe Jamison and G. M. McClellen may be mentioned as exceptions. They chose not to write in dialect, which, as Sterling Brown has suggested,  “meant a rejection of stereotypes of Negro life,”  and they refused to write only about racial subjects. This refusal had both a positive and a negative consequence. As Brown observes, “Valuably insisting that Negro poets should not be confined to issues of race, these poets committed   error... they refused to look into their hearts and write.” These are important insights, but one must stress that this refusal to look within was also typical of most White poets of the United States at the time. They, too, often turned from their own experience and consequently produced not very memorable poems about vague topics, such as the peace of nature.    1 
 1. According to the passage, most turn-of-the-century Black poets generally did which of the following?

(A) Wrote in ways that did not challenge accepted literary practice.
(B) Described scenes from their own lives.
(C) Aroused patriotic feelings by expressing devotion to the land.
(D) Expressed complex feelings in the words of ordinary people.
(E) Interpreted the frustrations of Blacks to an audience of Whites.

2 
 2. According to the passage, an issue facing Black poets in the 1920’s was whether they should

(A) seek a consensus on new techniques of poetry
(B) write exclusively about and for Blacks
(C) withdraw their support from a repressive society
(D) turn away from social questions to recollect the tranquility of nature
(E) identify themselves with an international movement of Black writers

3 
 3. It can be inferred from the passage that classifying a poet as either conservative or experimental would be of “little significance” ( Highlighted ) when discussing Black poets of the 1910’s and the 1920’s because

(A) these poets wrote in very similar styles
(B) these poets all wrote about nature in the same way
(C) these poets were fundamentally united by a sense of racial achievement despite differences in poetic style
(D) such a method of classification would fail to take account of the influence of general poetic practice
(E) such a method of classification would be relevant only in a discussion of poets separated in time by more than three decades

4 
 4. The author quotes Sterling Brown in  Highlighted  lines in order to

(A) present an interpretation of some black poets that contradicts the author’s own assertion about their acceptance of various poetic styles
(B) introduce a distinction between Black poets who used dialect and White poets who did not
(C) disprove James Weldon Johnson’s claim that race is what “the Negro poet knows best”
(D) suggest what were the effects of some Black poets’ decision not to write only about racial subjects
(E) prove that Black poets at the turn of the century wrote less conventionally than did their White counterparts

5 
 5. It can be inferred from the passage that the author finds the work of the majority of the Black poets at the turn of the century to be

(A) unexciting
(B) calming
(C) confusing
(D) delightful
(E) inspiring

6 
 6. The author would be most likely to agree that poets tend to produce better poems when they

(A) express a love of nature
(B) declaim noble emotions
(C) avoid technical questions about style
(D) emulate the best work of their predecessors
(E) write from personal experience

7 
 7. Which of the following best describes the attitude of the author toward classification as a technique in literary history?

(A) Enthusiastic
(B) Indifferent
(C) Wary
(D) Derisive
(E) Defensive

LipiSinha · Accepted Answer

Q1.
 A. Yes. The author mentions in the passage that these poets wrote in the conventional manner and chose not to write in dialects.

B. No. They refused to write about racial subjects. No evidence in the passage of poetry on other different aspects of their life.

C. No. Out of Scope.

D. No. Out of Scope.

E. No. Out of Scope.

Q2.
A. No. Irrelevant

B. Yes. Explicitly stated in the 3rd paragraph, "However, in the 1920’s Black poets did debate whether they should deal with specifically racial subjects. They asked whether they should only write about Black experience for a Black audience or whether such demands were restrictive".

C. No. Out of Scope.

D. No. Irrelevant. Not supported by the passage.

E. No. Out of Scope.

Q3.
A. No. No evidence of this in passage.

B. No. No evidence of this in passage.

C. Yes. In the 2nd paragraph, "But Black poets were not battling over old or new styles; rather, one accomplished Black poet was ready to welcome another, whatever his or her style, for what mattered was racial pride."

D. No. Irrelevant.

E. No. No evidence of this in passage.

Q4. 
A. No. The passage contains no interpretation of any black poet.

B. No. No such distinction has been presented in the passage.

C. No. This claim of Johnson is for the 1920s black poets.

D. Yes. The line followed by the highlighted line states, "This refusal had both a positive and a negative consequence."

E. No. This is not what Sterling Brown suggested through his claim.

Q5.
 A. Yes. In the last paragraph the author mentions, "At the turn of the century, by contrast, most Black poets generally wrote in the conventional manner of the age and expressed noble, if vague, emotions in their poetry." And then he states that White poets of the same time too "from their own experience and consequently produced not very memorable poems about vague topics".

Q6.
A. No. The author considers this as a vague topic.

B. No. No evidence of this in the passage.

C. No. Irrelevant.

D. No. Out of scope.

E. Yes. In the 3rd paragraph, the author states, "It may be said, though, that virtually all these poets wrote their best poems when they spoke out of racial feeling". And then in the last paragraph, when he talks about the turn of century black poets, he says that their poetry contained vague emotions (because they "refused to looks into their hearts and write").

Q7.
 C. Wary. The author states in the beginning of the passage, "The making of classifications by literary historians can be a somewhat risky enterprise. When Black poets are discussed separately as a group, for instance, the extent to which their work reflects the development of poetry in general should not be forgotten, or a distortion of literary history may result."

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot:

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

This post was generated automatically.

The making of classifications by literary historians can be a somewhat

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

The making of classifications by literary historians can be a somewhat

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards