Each spring, Northbridge University runs a weeklong alumni phone-a-thon. In a typical year, the phone-a-thon results in about 400 alumni signing up to mentor current students. Therefore, if the university were to discontinue the phone-a-thon, the number of alumni who sign up to mentor students each year would decline by about 400.
NU runs a weeklong alumni phone a thon... 400 alumni sign up to mentor current students..
if NU discontinues the phone a thon then the number of alumni who sign up to mentor each year would decline by 400
Assumption based ; use negation technique and weaken the conclusion
Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
A. The phone-a-thon costs the university
more than the value of 400 alumni mentors’ time.
this does not weaken the conclusion
B. The university would still
not be able to contact alumni through email if the phone-a-thon were discontinued.
reasoning does not weaken the conclusion
C.
All alumni who currently sign up to mentor through the phone-a-thon would sign up through other university outreach efforts if the phone-a-thon were discontinued.
there will be other means like online or letter etc via which the alumni will still continue to connect and sign up .. this weakens the conclusion , correct option
D. The alumni who sign up to mentor through the phone-a-thon
are substantially more likely than other alumni to sign up to mentor in any given year, regardless of how they are contacted.
this is not relevant to argument and does not weaken the conclusion
E. The university’s other mentoring sign-up channels
would become significantly more effective at attracting mentors if the phone-a-thon were discontinued.
this does not weaken the conclusion strongly enough than option C
OPTION C is correct