How many different arrangements of A, B, C, D, and E are pos

Question

How many different arrangements of A, B, C, D, and E are possible where A is adjacent to neither B nor D?

(A) 96 
 (B) 60 
 (C) 48 
 (D) 36 
 (E) 17

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

Total # of permutation of 5 distinct letters will be 5!=120;

Glue A and B together, consider it to be one unit: {AB}{C}{D}{E} --> # of permutation of these 4 units will be 4!=24, A and B within its unit also can be arranged in 2 ways : {AB} or {BA}, so total # of ways to arrange A, B, C, D, and E so that A and B to be together will be 4!*2=48;

The same for A and D: total # of ways to arrange A, B, C, D, and E so that A and D to be together will be 4!*2=48;

Now, the above 48+48=96 cases will contain the arrangements when A is adjacent to both B and D, so we should subtract this cases to get rid of the double counting. The # of case when A is adjacent to both B and D will be: consider {BAD} {C}{E} --> # of permutation of these 3 units will be 3!, {BAD} also can be arranged in 2 ways: {BAD} or {DAB}, so total # of ways to arrange A, B, C, D, and E so that A is adjacent to both B and D will be 3!*2=12;

The # of arrangements when A is adjacent to neither B nor D will be total-(48+48-12)=120-84=36.

Answer: D.

Bunuel · Answer

Another way: as A must be adjacent to neither B nor D then it must be adjacent to only C or only E or both.

Adjacent to both: {CAE}{B}{D} --> # of permutation of these 3 units will be 3!, {CAE} also can be arranged in 2 ways: {CAE} or {EAC}, so total # of ways to arrange A, B, C, D, and E so that A is adjacent to both C and E will be 3!*2=12;

Adjacent to only C: AC-XXX (A is the first letter and C is the second): these X-s can be arranged in 3! ways. Now, it can also be XXX-CA (A is the last letter and C is the fourth): again these X-s can be arranged in 3! ways. So total # of ways to arrange A, B, C, D, and E so that A is adjacent to only C is 3!*2=12;

The same will be when A is adjacent to only E: 3!*2=12;

Total: 12+12+12=36.

Answer: D.

Bunuel · Answer

Bumping for review and further discussion*. Get a kudos point for an alternative solution!

*New project from GMAT Club!!! Check HERE

Theory on Combinations: math-combinatorics-87345.html

DS questions on Combinations: search.php?search_id=tag&tag_id=31
PS questions on Combinations: search.php?search_id=tag&tag_id=52

Tough and tricky questions on Combinations: hardest-area-questions-probability-and-combinations-101361.html

vs129 · Answer

If the first letter is A, there are two options for the second letter (C or E), the remaining 3 letters can be arranged in 3! ways, thus there are 2*6=12 arrangements with A as the first letter. Similarly, if A were the last letter , there are 12 different arrangements. If A were in any one of the 3 intermediate positions, it wld have to be in between C and E - thus there would be 2 (betn C and E) *2 (betn B and D) =4 different arrangements for each of the 3 intermediate positions. Thus total number of diff arrangements = 12 (A is the first letter) + 12 (A is the last letter) + 4*3 (in any of the 3 intermediate posns) = 36.

jlgdr · Answer

Looks good only thing I got wrong was that on the last step namely: 'Now, the above 48+48=96 cases will contain the arrangements when A is adjacent to both B and D, so we should subtract this cases to get rid of the double counting. The # of case when A is adjacent to both B and D will be: consider {BAD} {C}{E} --> # of permutation of these 3 units will be 3!, {BAD} also can be arranged in 2 ways: {BAD} or {DAB}, so total # of ways to arrange A, B, C, D, and E so that A is adjacent to both B and D will be 3!*2=12;' I subtracted 12 twice that is 24, because BAD and DAB are included in both the first case with AB together and the second case with AD together Could you please explain why you only subtract once and not twice, I've made this error several times already and I can't seem to get the grip on this issue Thanks! Cheers J

Bunuel · Answer

(a) The cases for which A and B are together (48) include the cases cases when A is adjacent to both B and C: {the cases when A is adjacent only to B} + {the cases when A is adjacent to both B and C}.

(b) The cases for which A and C are together (48) include the cases cases when A is adjacent to both B and C: {the cases when A is adjacent only to C} + {the cases when A is adjacent to both B and C}.

(c) The number of cases when A is adjacent to both B and C is 12.

Now, to get the number of cases for which A is adjacent to B, or C or both = {the cases when A is adjacent only to B} + {the cases when A is adjacent only to C} + {the cases when A is adjacent to both B and C}, which is (a) + (b) - (c).

Basically the same way as when we do for overlapping sets when we subtract {both}: {total} = {group 1} + {group 2} - {both}.

Does this make sense?

jlgdr · Answer

Oh ok, gotcha. Yeah the thing is that when in overlapping sets you only want to count the members of Set A or B, but not both then it is correct to subtract 'Both' two times.

Say like How many of the multiples of 3 and 5 are not multiples of 15?

Then you would only take the multiples of 3 and 5 and subtract 2* (Multiples of 15).

This reasoning doesn't quite apply to this question as we do in fact want to consider the scenario in which all three are seated together.
Therefore, we should use {both}: {total} = {group 1} + {group 2} - {both} as you correctly mentioned

Clear now
Thanks
Cheers!
J

GMATinsight · Answer

ALTERNATE METHOD :

We can make cases here

Case 1: A takes position no.1 i.e. Arrangement looks like (A _ _ _ _)

In this case B and D can take any two position out of position no.3, 4, and 5
i.e. B and D can take position in 3x2 = 6 ways
remaining two letters C and E can be arranged on remaining two places in 2! ways = 2 ways

i.e. total arrangement as per Case 1 = 6 x 2 = 12 ways

Case 2: A takes position no.2 i.e. Arrangement looks like (_ A _ _ _)

In this case B and D can take any two position out of position no. 4 and 5
i.e. B and D can take position in 2! = 2 ways
remaining two letters C and E can be arranged on remaining two places in 2! ways = 2 ways

i.e. total arrangement as per Case 2 = 2 x 2 = 4 ways

Case 3: A takes position no.3 i.e. Arrangement looks like (_ _ A _ _)

In this case B and D can take any two position out of position no. 1 and 5
i.e. B and D can take position in 2! = 2 ways
remaining two letters C and E can be arranged on remaining two places in 2! ways = 2 ways

i.e. total arrangement as per Case 3 = 2 x 2 = 4 ways

Case 4: A takes position no.4 i.e. Arrangement looks like (_ _ _ A _)    This case is same as Case 2 (Just mirror of case 2) hence total ways of arrangement will remain 4 ways only

In this case B and D can take any two position out of position no. 1 and 2
i.e. B and D can take position in 2! = 2 ways
remaining two letters C and E can be arranged on remaining two places in 2! ways = 2 ways

i.e. total arrangement as per Case 4 = 2 x 2 = 4 ways

Case 5: A takes position no.5 i.e. Arrangement looks like (_ _ _ _ A)   This case is same as Case 2 (Just mirror of case 1) hence total ways of arrangement will remain 4 ways only

In this case B and D can take any two position out of position no.1, 2, and 3
i.e. B and D can take position in 3x2 = 6 ways
remaining two letters C and E can be arranged on remaining two places in 2! ways = 2 ways

i.e. total arrangement as per Case 5 = 6 x 2 = 12 ways

Total Ways of favorable arrangements = 12+4+4+4+12 = 36 ways

Answer: Option  D

manhasnoname · Answer

A will be adjacent to B or D, in any of the permutations of ABD.

So total permutations of "CE " is 3! * 3!

Total permutations of "ABCDE" is 5!.

Shouldn't the answer be 5! - 3! * 3!. What is it that I'm missing ?

law258 · Answer

I'm a visual person, so maybe my explanation will help those who are having difficulty seeing what's going on in this problem:
Given that we have 5 different letters to order, there are 5 places A could be situated - thus, we will devise 5 cases

(1) A __ __ __ __ 
(2) __ A __ __ __ 
(3) __ __ A __ __ 
(4) __ __ __ A __ 
(5) __ __ __ __ A

We also know that B or D cannot be adjacent to A, so we will adjust our scenarios to reflect such:

(1) A (~B/D) __ __ __ 
(2) (~B/D) A (~B/D) __ __ 
(3) __ (~B/D) A (~B/D) __ 
(4) __ __ (~B/D) A (~B/D) 
(5) __ __ __ (~B/D) A

Now, looking at the scenarios, starting with (1), we see that position two will have to be taken by either C or E. This will give us two baseline scenarios to work off of

(a) A C __ __ __ 
(b) A E __ __ __

Now the remaining three slots available can be occupied by a combination of the remaining 3 letters --> 3! 
Thus, for each scenario within main scenario (1) (i.e. A in first slot), we will have 12 combinations (i.e. 6 each)

This will also be the case for (5), since A will be basically flipped to the opposite side --> so we can say right now that (5) will also have 12 combinations

(2) C/E A C/E __ __ --> breaks down into two scenarios again

(a) C A E __ __ --> two combinations (with remaining letters)
(b) E A C __ __ --> two combinations (with remaining letters)

Thus (2) gives us 4 combinations

(4) will also give us 4 combinations for the same reason

(3) __ C/E A C/E __ remains --> break into scenarios once more

(a) __ C A E __ --> 2 combinations possible (with remaining letters)
(b) __ E A C __ --> 2 combinations possible (with remaining letters)

Thus, adding (1)+(2)+(3)+(4)+(5) = 36 combinations

KarishmaB · Answer

If A can be adjacent to neither B nor D, it would be either nestled between E and C or at an extreme position next to E or next to C.

No of cases with A nestled between E and C = 3! * 2! = 12

No of cases with A at left extreme with C/E next to it = 2*3! = 12 (Choose one of C or E in 2 ways and arrange the remaining 3 letters)

No of cases with A at right extreme with C/E next to it = 12 (same as above)

Total = 12+12+12 = 36

Answer (D)

SVaidyaraman · Answer

Leftmost arrangement of constraint elements is

A_BD_ Using formula we have (2!*2)*3*2!=24

B_A_D Using formula we have 2!*3!*1=12

The total number of permutations is 36

For explanation of this formula and other types of problems kindly visit the link below.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot:

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

This post was generated automatically.

How many different arrangements of A, B, C, D, and E are pos

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

How many different arrangements of A, B, C, D, and E are pos

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards