Hi theretheree4,Good news first:
you're not missing anything. Your method is completely valid, and it's the same plug-in approach several people used in this thread (Bunuel with n=
2, gmat1220 with n=
6).
What you did:
- First
4 integers:
1+2+3+4 = 10 = S- First
4 even integers:
2+4+6+8 = 20 = 2SThat's a legitimate way to get to
C. There's no rule you overlooked - you basically
rediscovered why the answer is
2S: every even term is just double its matching counting number (
2 = 2·
1,
4 = 2·
2, ...), so the whole sum doubles.
The one habit to addWhen you test with a single number, there's a small risk worth knowing about: sometimes
more than one answer choice produces your target value, and then a single case can't tell them apart. KarishmaB flagged exactly this earlier in the thread - she noted that if an option like
2S2 had been present, one value of n might not be enough to separate it from the right answer.
So the safe move is a quick scan: does
only one choice hit your value? Using your S =
10:
- A) S/
2 =
5- B) S =
10- C)
2S =
20 ✓
- D)
2S+2 =
22- E)
4S =
40Only
C gives
20, so your single test is airtight here. You're done.
Why the caution matters (quick illustration)Watch how a small number can create a tie. Suppose a choice
2S2 had been on the list, and you'd picked the smallest case, n=
1, so S =
1:
-
2S = 2·
1 =
2-
2S2 = 2·
12 =
2 - same value!
Now one case can't decide between them. Test a second case, n=
2, so S =
3:
-
2S =
6-
2S2 = 2·
32 =
18 - now they split apart.
That's the whole reason to glance at the other choices (or try a second n): to make sure your number didn't accidentally match two answers. In
this question it didn't, so your approach nailed it.
Answer: Ctheretheree4
Can someone let me know is there any formula or rule that they are using because I can simply take a four values like 1234 and using the sum formula by n/2(first+last) I get 10 and if do for positive even that is 2468, I’ll get the 20 so I can directly say it’s twice. What am I missing here?