simonsays452
I've gotten into both McCombs and Johnson and I'm still waiting to hear back from Fuqua, my number one choice. Assuming I don't get into Duke, I'm really torn between Texas and Cornell.
McCombs definitely wins re: location and students but I want to be back in NYC in PE/VC and I'm worried McComb's concentration in Texas will limit my NYC options.
At the same time thought, I think McComb's Venture Fellows program is a better option as compared to Cornell's BRV Fund.
Texas is 21 for finance, Cornell is 24 but Cornell is 16 overall and Texas is 17 overall.
What complicates things further is that Cornell's deposit is due the same day Duke issues their notification and three days before McComb's Preview Weekend.
Ideally I'd like a better quality of life (Texas) but my gut tells me networking at Cornell will benefit me more in transitioning into PE/VC in Manhattan and I can live anywhere for a year and a half...even if it's Ithaca.
Thoughts??
I don't know what to do with the deposit dilemma, but in terms of McCombs vs Johnson my thought would be Johnson, at least for you, without a doubt. Funny thing is that I faced an almost exact opposite decision as you, so I chose McCombs in a heartbeat.
One of the main reasons I McCombs was ideal for me was that, as a Texas resident who wants to stay here post-graduation, McCombs is unrivaled in the State of Texas. It has a great and growing rep on the west and east coasts, but my experience was that after the top 5-10 schools, there is a certain degree of regional bias. I chose McCombs because most of the people who graduate do end up staying in Texas. Ideal for me, not so much for you. I was about to apply to Johnson, and started writing up the apps, but didn't turn them in once I got the McCombs admit. Main reason why I was hesitant about applying? Because the majority of people who graduate from Johnson end up in New York, and I didn't want to target that area. It would have taken me a lot of leg work, and an uphill battle (and I'd be at a disadvantage to other students who went to local Texas schools), if I was recruiting from New York. Reverse Texas and New York in the last statement for your scenario and I think the picture is a bit clearer.
I love Texas, and I really liked Johnson (I have a friend who goes to another grad program at Cornell, so i got to visit the Bschool while up there). The area is beautiful, you just have to bear the winters (if you're not used to snow, as I'm not, then you better start working on that!