12 Days of Christmas GMAT Competition - Day 2: A car is randomly

Question

12 Days of Christmas 2024 - 2025 Competition with $40,000 of Prizes

If a car is randomly selected from a factory's production line, what is the probability that the selected car is electric?

(1) The probability that a car selected at random is neither red nor electric is 1/3.
(2) The probability that a car selected at random is red but not electric is 2/15.

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

GMAT Club's Official Explanation:

If a car is randomly selected from a factory's production line, what is the probability that the selected car is electric?

This question is essentially about overlapping groups framed as a probability problem. We use the formula:

Total = Electric + Red - Both + Neither

Our goal is to calculate Electric/Total * 100. To make calculations easier, let's assume Total = 45 (the least common multiple of the denominators from the statements).

(1) The probability that a car selected at random is neither red nor electric is 1/3.

45 = Electric + Red - Both + 15

Not sufficient.

(2) The probability that a car selected at random is red but not electric is 2/15.

The above implies:

Red - Both = 6.

Not sufficient.

(1) + (2) Substituting Red - Both = 6 into 45 = Electric + Red - Both + 15, we get 45 = Electric + 6 + 15, which simplifies to Electric = 24. Therefore, Electric/Total * 100 = 24/45 * 100. Sufficient.

Answer: C

giuseppemvn · Answer

Q: Probability that a randomly selected car is electric.

Statement 1

First statement gives us probability of choosing a car NOT Red and NOT Electric. We can calculate the probability of selecting a car both red and electric, but it's not what the question asks. Statement 1 is not sufficient.

Statement 2

Second statement gives us probability that a randomly selected car is red and NOT Electric. Statement 2 is not sufficient for the same reason explained above.

Statement 1 + Statement 2

If we combine both informations we have P(Red, Not electric) and P(Not red, Not electric). If we sum these two we get the total probability of a car being not electric. This event and the car being electric instead are mutually exclusive and collectively exhaustive, thus:

P(E) + P(NE) = 1

So:

P(E) = 1 - P(NE)

Statement 1 + Statement 2 are sufficient.

Answer  C

hr1212 · Answer

Let R stand for red, NR for non-red, E for electric and NE for non-electric then,

Statement 1 -

R 
 NR 
 T 
 
  E

? 
 
  NE 
  
 1/3

T

1

Not sufficient

Statement 2 -

R 
 NR 
 T 
 
  E

? 
 
  NE 
 2/15

T

1

Not sufficient

Combining both these statements -

R 
 NR 
 T 
 
  E

8/15  
 
  NE 
 2/15 
 1/3 
 7/15 
 
  T

1

Answer : C

Krunaal · Answer

There are 4 possibilities Red & Electric (RE), Not Red & Electric (NRE), Not Red & Not Electric (NRNE), and Red & Not Electric (RNE)

We need to find,  (RE + NRE) / All possible cases

Statement 1

NRNE / All possible cases =  1/3 NOT SUFFICIENT

Statement 2

RNE / All possible cases =  2/15 NOT SUFFICIENT

Both Together

(NRNE / All possible cases) + (RNE / All possible cases) = 7/15

(RE + NRE) / All possible cases = 1 - 7/15 = 8/15  SUFFICIENT

Answer C.

Kinshook · Answer

If a car is randomly selected from a factory's production line, what is the probability that the selected car is electric?

(1) The probability that a car selected at random is neither red nor electric is 1/3.

Red 
 Not Red 
 Total 
 
  Electric

x=? 
 
  Not Electric 
  
 1/3 
 1-x 
 
  Total

1

The probability that the selected car is electric can not be found out with the given information.
NOT SUFFICIENT

(2) The probability that a car selected at random is red but not electric is 2/15.

Red 
 Not Red 
 Total 
 
  Electric

x=? 
 
  Not Electric 
 2/15 
  
 1-x 
 
  Total

1

The probability that the selected car is electric can not be found out with the given information.
NOT SUFFICIENT

(1) + (2)
(1) The probability that a car selected at random is neither red nor electric is 1/3.
(2) The probability that a car selected at random is red but not electric is 2/15.

Red 
 Not Red 
 Total 
 
  Electric

x=1 - 7/15 = 8/15 
 
  Not Electric 
 2/15 
 1/3 
 1-x = 2/15+1/3 = 7/15 
 
  Total

1

The probability that the selected car is electric is 8/15
SUFFICIENT

IMO C

Rex885 · Answer

Red 
 Not red

Electric

not electric

Total

Making this table is super useful in case of overlapping sets question.

St 1) Prob. neither red not electric =1/3
Prob={#favourable cases/total cases}

Red 
 Not red

Electric

not electric 
  
 y

3y

Clearly NS alone

St 2) Prob. red but not electric is 2/15

Red 
 Not red

Electric

not electric 
 2x

15x

Clearly NS alone

BUT ON COMBINING THEM

Red 
 Not red

Electric

not electric 
 2x 
 y 
 2x+y=7x

15x=3y

now 15x=3y i.e. y=5x
this implies total electric cars are 15x-7x=8x

Hence prob. of electric car = 8/15
SUFFICIENT

missionmba2025 · Answer

Red 
 Not Red

Electric

We need to find this 
 
  Non Electric

Total

1

(1) The probability that a car selected at random is neither red nor electric is 1/3.

Red 
 Not Red

Electric

We need to find this 
 
  Non Electric 
  
 1/3

Total

1

The information given is not sufficient as we can't reach to the required information. Hence, eliminate A, and D.

(2) The probability that a car selected at random is red but not electric is 2/15.

Red 
 Not Red

Electric

We need to find this 
 
  Non Electric 
 2/15

Total

1

The information given is not sufficient as we can't reach to the required information. Hence, eliminate B.

Combined

Red 
 Not Red

Electric

We need to find this 
 
  Non Electric 
 2/15 
 1/3

Total

1

We can calculate the probability of non electric vehicles. By subtracting the obtained probability, we can get the probability of electric vehicles.

Option C

nishantswaft · Answer

It is given to us that; 
 a car is randomly selected from a factory's production line  
 Then the question asks us what is the probability that the selected car is electric? 
 It is a value type of DS question.

Let's form a table.

RED 
 NOT RED 
 TOTAL 
 
  ELECTRIC

E 
 
  NOT ELECTRIC

TOTAL

T

We have to find, value of E/T?

Let’s look at statement 1; 
 The probability that a car selected at random is neither red nor electric is 1/3. 
So we can fill our table as:- 
    
 RED 
 NOT RED 
 TOTAL 
 
  ELECTRIC

NOT ELECTRIC 
  
 x

TOTAL

3x

No other information is given to us here.
 So S1 is not sufficient. 
 (Eliminate A and D)

Let’s look at statement 2; 
 The probability that a car selected at random is red but not electric is 2/15.  
 So we can fill our table as:-

RED  
  NOT RED  
  TOTAL  
 
   ELECTRIC

NOT ELECTRIC  
  2y

TOTAL

15y

No other information is given to us here.
 So S2 is not sufficient. 
 (Eliminate B)

Combining 1 and 2; we have;

RED  
  NOT RED  
  TOTAL  
 
   ELECTRIC

E=8y  
 
   NOT ELECTRIC  
  2y  
  x=5y  
  7y  
 
   TOTAL

3x=15y

3x=15y then x=5y,
Filling our table further we have;
 E=15y-7y=8y 
 and T=15y 
 So, required probability = 8/15

The answer is C.

Lizaza · Answer

This task is easiest to solve via Venn diagram (attached), because effectively the probability of selecting a type of cars is equal to its share of the total area. Let's draw all possible cars, in which we have both red and electric ones - but we need to remember that we have no information about what other types of cars are there.

The empty space around our circles effectively means neither red nor electric - hence, the two circles together make 2/3.  Insufficient .

The only-red circle (or the half-moon figure on the left, rather) is 2/15, which tells nothing about electric cars.  Insufficient .

Knowing that both circles make 2/3, and that the left half-moon makes 2/15, we are surprisingly left with the whole circle of electric cars, which is   E=\frac{2}{3}-\frac{2}{15}=\frac{8}{15} .  Sufficient .

Therefore,   the answer is C.

Purnank · Answer

lets assume E as probability of car being electric and R as probability of car being red.
We need to find - E?

1st - The probability that a car selected at random is neither red nor electric is 1/3.
(RUE)' = 1 - RUE =  \frac{1}{3} 
and, RUE = R + E - R∩E

\frac{1}{3} = 1 - R - E + R∩E 
after solving we get,

R + E - R∩E = \frac{2}{3}

Not sufficient.

2nd - The probability that a car selected at random is red but not electric is 2/15.

R - R∩E = \frac{2}{15}

Not sufficient.

Now if we combine both statements we can get E,

E + \frac{2}{15} = \frac{2}{3} 
After solving,

E = \frac{8}{15}

Answer is C.

OmerKor · Answer

Hi Everyone

Double Matrix Question: Electric No Electric Total Red No Red Total Our Answer 100% (1) No Red & No Electric = 1/3 Electric No Electric Total Red any values equal or less then 2/3 No Red Total Our Answer 100% InSuff (2) Red & No Electric = 2/15 Electric No Electric Total Red No Red any values equal or less then 2/15 Total Our Answer 100% InSuff (1)+(2) Electric No Electric Total Red No Red Total 100% Our answer: 8/15

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot:

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

This post was generated automatically.

12 Days of Christmas GMAT Competition - Day 2: A car is randomly

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

	Red	Not Red	Total
Electric			x=1 - 7/15 = 8/15
Not Electric	2/15	1/3	1-x = 2/15+1/3 = 7/15
Total			1

	Electric	No Electric	Total
Red		any values equal or less then 2/3
No Red		[1][/3]
Total	Our Answer		100%

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

12 Days of Christmas GMAT Competition - Day 2: A car is randomly

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards