fleurdelisse
rid82
I didn't want to create any controversy with that post.
I had read some post before about how good was the portal, and when I finally received my login credentials and log in the system, I didn't like it as much as I thought I would. That's why I said I was a bit disappointed.
I didn't have time to go deep in any of both portals. If you are LBS student in an exchange in Booth, you will probably know them much better than me.
Anyway, as I said, in my opinion, the first impression I got after playing with them is that Booth's was far better.
In fact, I have the impression that at Booth everything is very well organized. Since the day I have been admitted to both schools, Booth is doing much better job than LBS to convince me and my wife to join the school (apart from the scholarship stuff).
By the way, I would love to have your opinion about Booth vs LBS, as we are still considering both options. In any case I'm very interested in exchanging in the other.
I applied to Carnegie Mellon as a safe choice and I have to tell you the package they sent is very appealing and much more comprehensive than LBS. Their website is more detailed, and I have been contacted twice so far by students and the admissions office to congratulate me on the offer. Does this mean it's a better school? No.
Marketing is an important factor in a school's image but definitly not the defining one.
I also think it's a difference between US and European service in general. Usually, US institutions are much better at direct marketing and much more personalized than their European counterparts.
That said, I am not undermining Booth. It's a great school, and not merely because of its portal or its friendly staff. It has some of the greatest faculty, a very strong focus on finance and economics, and a strong network in the US.
So the question really comes down to where you plan to work post-MBA. If it's in the US, then go with Booth no questions asked and you can do an exchange program with LBS if you want to get the European experience. Whereas if you plan to work in Europe, then LBS is your best bet. Not only because of reputation in Europe but also for the opportunities to network with companies on the ground.
Finally, cost-wise, LBS might be more suitable since you can finish the program in as little as 15 months.
just to be clear, I'm not making my decision because of how pretty is the admission website.
I've talked during the last 3 weeks with many people, including current and former students of both schools, family, friends, etc. I think both schools are great and it is not an easy decision, as I believe I will receive a great education and a good job no matter which school I join.
LBS is clearly better in terms of international diversity (I've been living in three different continents the last 6 years so this is important for me).
But I don't agree with "if you want to work in Europe, go to LBS" that some people say. Yes, I think LBS has a strong presence in Europe, bigger than Chicago. However, correct me if I'm wrong but I heard somewhere that almost 75% of LBS graduates work in London post-MBA, and something like 5-10% go to the US. I'm not interested in working in London, and if one day I want to do so, Booth also has a strong presence there. In other European countries (like mine) I believe there is not a big difference whether you graduate from LBS or Booth. I'm considering a Consulting post-MBA job in my country and I believe I will have similar chances to find a job in M/B/B whether I graduate from LBS or from Booth.
Regarding faculty, I didn't find anyone that told me that LBS has better professors. In fact, two current students told me that they had been (a bit) disappointed with the quality of professors at LBS this year.
Apart from that, I prefer the city of Chicago and the US than London. Its more appealing to me, cannot tell you exactly why. As I said I'm from a western European country and London, though appealing, is not the same thing as studying in a top US school. In addition, facilities at Booth seems to be awesome and the cost of living is like half of London's.
Finally, last but not least, Chicago offered my wife half of tuition as a scholarship (about $50k) so this is something important to consider as we have to pay 2 MBAs. Another one is that in my country there are some scholarships that cover the 100% of the cost of the MBA, and are very competitive. Going to a top 5 US school helps more to receive the scholarship than going to LBS.
I will make my final decision very soon and 90% I will withdraw my application.