Bill can dig a well in x! hours. Carlos can dig the same

Question

Bill can dig a well in x! hours. Carlos can dig the same well in y! hours. If q is the number of hours that it takes Bill and Carlos to dig the well together, working at their respective rates, is q an integer?

(1) x - y = 1
(2) y is a nonprime even number.

(1) x - y = 1 
(2) y is a nonprime even number.

gurpreetsingh · Answer

As per given conditions:

\frac{1}{x!}+ \frac{1}{y!}=\frac{1}{q}  =>  q = \frac{(x!*y!)}{(x!+y!)} 
Statement 2: no condition about X, thus not sufficient.

Statement 1: x -y=1 => x = y+1 =>  x! = (y+1)y!

q = \frac{(x!*y!)}{(x!+y!)} = y!*y!* \frac{(y+1)}{(y!*(y+2))}

=>  q = \frac{(y+1)!}{(y+2)}

if y = 2 q = 3!/4 = 3/2 not an integer
if y = 4 Q= 5!/6 = 20 = integer

Thus not sufficient.

Considering both the statement y cannot be 2, for all even values of y except 2, q is an integer.

Thus C

rohitgoel15 · Answer

Thanks Gurpreet!
But can you please explain the below steps a bit more. Lost track and couldnt follow u.
Statement 1: x -y=1 => x = y+1 => x! = (y+1)y!
and the next step as well!

ulm · Answer

To understand this, try digits.
y=5
x=5+1=6
6!=1*2*3*4*5*6
or 
(5+1)5! = (5+1)*1*2*3*4*5

gurpreetsingh · Answer

x-y=1
=> x=y+1

=> x! = (y+1)! = (y+1)*y!

use the property....x! = x*(x-1) *(x-2) .....1------------------1

(x-1)! = (x-1)*(x-2)*......1------------------------------------2

Using equation 1 and 2
we get x! = (x)*(x-1)!

varunmaheshwari · Answer

As per stmt 1: x-y=1 +> x=y+1
thus x! = (y+1)!

Now q = (x! * y!) / (x! + y!) 
=> q = ((y+1)! * y!) / ((y+1)! + y!)

Taking y! as common in both numerator and denominator

q = y!*(y+1)! / y!*(y+1 +1) 
=> q = (y+1)! / (y+2)

Hope this helps!!

gmat1011 · Answer

q = x!*y!/x!+y! = Integer?

Since (1) says x-y=1

x, y are consecutive integers

3!+4! can be written as 3!(4+1)
Similarly x!+y! = y!(x+1)

=> q = x!*y!/y!(x+1) = x!/x+1

x!/x+1 is an integer only if x is an odd integer greater than 3

(1) x-y = 1 (odd) so we know that out of x and y 1 is odd and the other even. This is not enough.

(2) The info. in (2) alone is insufficient.

(1) and (2):

(2) tells us y is an even number but it is not 2 but an even number which is greater than 2 (it cannot be 0 as one can't dig a well in 0 hours). thus x-y =1 is not satisfied by x=2 and y=3.

Thus, y is is E and x is O (greater than 3). Thus, q = x!/x+1 we can conclude is an Integer based on (1) and (2). Ans. (C).

jassim.arif · Answer

Hi,

Can you please explain the following part a bit more clearly -

"Taking y! as common in both numerator and denominator"

q = y!*(y+1)! / y!*(y+1 +1)
 
=> q = (y+1)! / (y+2)

Bunuel · Answer

Simply reduce  \frac{y!*(y+1)!}{y!*(y+1+1)}  by y! to get  \frac{(y+1)!}{(y+1+1)}=\frac{(y+1)!}{(y+2)} .

Kavya123 · Answer

Is there a less time consuming solution?

akshayk · Answer

B =  \frac{1}{x!} 
C =  \frac{1}{y!} 
Together =  \frac{1}{q} 
=> q =  \frac{x!y!}{x!+y!} 
q = Integer ?

1) x - y = 1
x = 3, y = 2
q is not an integer
x = 4. y = 3
q =  \frac{4*3!*3!}{5*3!}  = not integer
x = 5, y = 4 => q = 20 (Integer)
Insufficient.

2) y is an even number other than 2
Insufficient. We know nothing about x

1+2)
x - y = 1
and y = even except 2
=> for all even values of y, q = integer.
x = 5, y = 4 =>  \frac{5*4!*4!}{6*4!}  = 20
x = 7, y = 6 =>  \frac{7*6!*6!}{8*6!}  = 630
Sufficient. Answer is C

mcm2112 · Answer

I have a different perspective, but someone let me know if I am off base. I tried to be more logical, than math based.
I set x=a+2 and y=a+3 and plugged for 1/x!+1/y!=1/q... 1/5!+1/4!--> 1/120+5/120 =6/120 = 20

I saw it this way. Any number you will get for \frac{1}{x!} will be odd and added to the \frac{1}{y!}. Any total factorial will be divisible by that number because it has factors built into the total.

To the above - 5! = 1*2*3*4*5 = 120 --- This must be divisible by 6 because 2*3 in the equation equals 6.

By giving that x! is a prime number, and we now our 1/x!+1/y! will always give us an even number. Any denominator will have factor that multiply to equal the numerator.

1/7!+1/6! -->1/5040+7/5040 = 8/5040 Because 2*4 is a part of 7!, we know it will result in an integer.

It makes sense in my madness...

stebbinn · Answer

The stem tells us that x+y=q.
--Essentially I just need to know if x and y are integers or if they add together to form an integer.

(1) tells us that x-y=1.
--This doesn't provide the answer I need, it just says that x and y are 1 apart.

(2) basically just tells us that y is an integer.
--This doesn't tell me anything about x or q so it doesn't provide the info I need either.

(1 & 2) 
I used a combination method to solve using the info from the stem and statement one to do the following:
 x-y=1
 -x+y=q 
-2y=1-q
2y+1=q

Now, using info from statement 2, we know that y is an integer and doubling an integer and adding 1 to it will give us an integer.

Hope this makes sense. Please let me know if you spot any errors! Thanks,

sidjain93 · Answer

Can you please give a easy way to do this 
 VeritasKarishma 
 GMATinsight

Applicant_22 · Answer

Shouldn't the answer be E,
Y can be 0, because 0! = 1, and while number of hours cannot be 0, y is not number of hours.
Also, 0 is a non prime even number without a doubt.
if Y = 0; 
Q = 1/2.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Bill can dig a well in x! hours. Carlos can dig the same

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards