Competition Mode Question
Union Official: Several workers who operate a certain type of machine have developed repetitive-motion injury, which is often caused by operation poorly designed machinery. Because physiologist employed by the machine's manufacturer have found that workers who maintain good posture while using the machine do not risk developing the condition, the manufacture argues that
the machine's design is not responsible for the worker's condition. However, when our own experts
conducted careful trial using both new and experienced machine operators, they concluded that the machine's design makes it difficult for workers to maintain good posture while operation it over long periods.
In the union official's argument, the two boldface portions play which of the following roles?
(A) The first gives the position that the union official supports; the second identifies the source of evidence that is offered in support of the union official's position.
(B) The first gives the position that the union official opposes; the second describes the source of evidence that is offered to undermine the manufacturer's position.
(C) The first gives the position that the union official opposes; the second identifies the source of evidence that was offered in support of the manufacturer's position.
(D) The first states an intermediate conclusion that is used to support a further conclusion; the second identifies the source of additional information that is offered in support of that further conclusion.
(E) The first provides evidence offered in support of the argument's conclusion; the second identifies the source of some additional evidence.