V37-14

Question

In the education sector, there is a significant variation in the adoption of digital learning tools across different school districts. Some districts have integrated technology extensively into their teaching methods, while others use it minimally. This variation is observed even among districts with similar demographics and funding levels.
 
To support a conclusion that much of this variation is due to reluctance or resistance to adopting new technology, it would be most important to establish which of the following?

A. Each school district has a committee that reviews and approves the educational technologies used in its schools.
B. The variation in the adoption of digital learning tools is not correlated with factors such as the availability of technology infrastructure or teacher training in technology use.
C. There are other educational methods and tools, besides digital learning tools, that also show similar patterns of regional variability in their adoption.
D. It is often difficult to measure the direct impact of digital learning tools on student performance, as many factors contribute to educational outcomes.
E. The trends in the adoption of digital learning tools in these districts are representative of broader trends in educational aid adoption by the districts in general.

Bunuel · Answer

Official Solution:

In the education sector, there is a significant variation in the adoption of digital learning tools across different school districts. Some districts have integrated technology extensively into their teaching methods, while others use it minimally. This variation is observed even among districts with similar demographics and funding levels.
 
To support a conclusion that much of this variation is due to reluctance or resistance to adopting new technology, it would be most important to establish which of the following?

A. Each school district has a committee that reviews and approves the educational technologies used in its schools.
B. The variation in the adoption of digital learning tools is not correlated with factors such as the availability of technology infrastructure or teacher training in technology use.
C. There are other educational methods and tools, besides digital learning tools, that also show similar patterns of regional variability in their adoption.
D. It is often difficult to measure the direct impact of digital learning tools on student performance, as many factors contribute to educational outcomes.
E. The trends in the adoption of digital learning tools in these districts are representative of broader trends in educational aid adoption by the districts in general.

B. The variation in the adoption of digital learning tools is not correlated with factors such as the availability of technology infrastructure or teacher training in technology use.
 
• This choice directly addresses the hypothesis that reluctance or resistance to adopting new technology might be driving the variation in the use of digital learning tools. If it can be established that the variation is not due to other factors (like infrastructure availability or teacher training), then the conclusion that the variation is due to reluctance or resistance becomes more plausible. This choice effectively isolates reluctance or resistance as the likely cause by eliminating other potential explanations.
 
The other options do not directly support the hypothesis as effectively as choice (B):
 
A. Each school district has a committee that reviews and approves the educational technologies used in its schools.
 
• While this might affect the adoption of technology, it doesn’t directly address the issue of whether variability is due to reluctance or resistance.
 
C. There are other educational methods and tools, besides digital learning tools, that also show similar patterns of regional variability in their adoption.
 
• This provides context but doesn’t specifically address the reason for the variability in the adoption of digital learning tools.
 
D. It is often difficult to measure the direct impact of digital learning tools on student performance, as many factors contribute to educational outcomes.
 
• While important, this point doesn’t directly relate to the question of why there is variability in the adoption of these tools across districts.
 
E. The trends in the adoption of digital learning tools in these districts are representative of broader trends in educational technology adoption in general.
 
• This option speaks to the representativeness of the trends related to education aids but does not touch technology reluctance specifically and if anything would weaken the conclusion.
 
 Therefore, (B) is the best choice for evaluating the conclusion that the variability in the adoption of digital learning tools is primarily due to reluctance or resistance to new technology.

Answer: B

8Harshitsharma · Answer

Hi Bunuel,

I have doubt on choice E. Doesn't choice E strengthen the claim that new technology is not being adopted in the districts with low digital learning tech adoption, thereby, strengthening the conclusion that people in these districts are reluctant to technology??

Regards

bb · Answer

Thank you for the question!
It seems choice E was supposed to be vague and talking about general trends. In defense of it being wrong, it is not clear if the broader trends adoption is referring to specific district adoption or industry in general. It is vague and unclear. However, you are not incorrect either because if you read it as the adoption of learning tools follows a trend in general tech adoption, then there is a pattern that the technology is not adopted.

This question was not designed to be tricky and supposed to be medium difficulty and this answer choice was not supposed to be a trap but a filler it seems so I will modify it to be more delineated, but you could eliminate it based on 2 factors: 1) Vague and unclear and 2) It requires multiple assumptions and that's not GMAT pattern. GMAT is very immediate - it gives you a fact that should be sufficient to to strengthen. You should not need a fact + assumption and only then it would strengthen. In other words, you only make 1 move/jump per square on the GMAT CR questions.

8Harshitsharma · Answer

Thank you for explaining, bb. That's an interesting way of putting it - the 1 move/jump limit in CR. I'll keep that in mind!

When I attempted the problem I recognized that B and E could both be correct answers maybe depending on whether the problem was a medium or a high-difficulty one so, I just guessed the answer at last.

Not to defend or anything but I'll present my thinking purely for sanity check. What drove me towards choice E was that choice B talks specifically about the absence of correlations and not definite causations (does it make 1 jump + assumption as well???). So I had to decide between one choice which is a defender stating some alternate correlations were absent, and the other choice was an observation that fills up the logical leap that the author has taken when concluding that these districts were reluctant to adopt "new technology", a leap from what he observed for "educational technology". Thus I ended up with E because it just seemed more concrete and direct strengthener.

Ngl, I felt it was a 705+ level question when I attempted it

Maybe you can craft one testing along similar lines

Regards

Maybe you can craft one testing along similar lines

Regards

V37-14

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards