If x and y are positive integers such that x y 1 and z=x/y, which

Question

If x and y are positive integers such that  x > y > 1  and  z = \frac{x}{y} , which of the following must be true?

I.  z > \frac{(x − 1)}{(y − 1)}

II.  z < \frac{(x − 1)}{(y − 1)}

III.  z > \frac{(x + 1)}{(y + 1)}

A. I​ only 
B. I and II​ 
C. II and III 
D. II only 
E. I​ and III

BrentGMATPrepNow · Accepted Answer

Notice that statements I and II say the exact OPPOSITE thing. 
Also, notice that either I or II appear in ALL 5 answer choices. So,  one of them must be true . 
Given this, let's see what happens when we assign some values to x and y.

Say x = 4 and y = 2
So, z = x/y = 4/2 =  2

Now test (x − 1)/(y − 1) by plugging in x = 4 and y = 2
We get: (4 - 1)/(2 - 1) = 3/1 = 3
Since z =  2 , we can see that z < (x − 1)/(y − 1)
So,  statement II is true , and statement I is false.

This means the correct answer is C or D

Now test statement III: z > (x + 1)/(y + 1)
Since z = x/y, we can rewrite III as x/y > (x + 1)/(y + 1) 
Let's find out if this statement is true. 
Since y is POSITIVE, we can safely multiply both sides by y to get: x > (y)(x + 1)/(y + 1)
y+1 is also POSITIVE, we can safely multiply both sides by y+1 to get: x(y + 1) > (y)(x + 1)
Expand both sides: xy + x > xy + y
Subtract xy from both sides to get: x > y
Is this true? YES! It's given in the question 
So  statement III is true

Answer:  C

RELATED VIDEO
 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Od98BOicIq4

chetan2u · Answer

Hi, lets see the choices I. z > \frac{(x − 1)}{(y − 1)} z=x/y so \frac{x}{y} >\frac{(x-1)}{(y-1)} .... \frac{x}{y} -\frac{(x-1)}{(y-1)}>0 ..... \frac{(xy-x-xy+y)}{y*(y-1)}>0 .. we know y>1 so y*(y-1)>0...so xy-x-xy+y>0 OR y>x NEVER true II. z < \frac{(x − 1)}{(y − 1)} .. z=\frac{x}{y} .. so \frac{x}{y} <\frac{(x-1)}{(y-1)} ..... \frac{x}{y} -\frac{(x-1)}{(y-1)}<0 ..... \frac{(xy-x-xy+y)}{y*(y-1)}<0 .. we know y>1 so y*(y-1)>0...so xy-x-xy+y<0 OR y \frac{(x + 1)}{(y + 1)} z=x/y so \frac{x}{y} >\frac{(x+1)}{(y+1)} ..... \frac{x}{y} -\frac{(x+1)}{(y+1)}>0 ..... \frac{(xy+x-xy-y)}{y*(y+1)}>0 .. we know y>1 so y*(y+1)>0...so xy+x-xy-y>0 OR x>y Always TRUE II and III are true ans C

davedekoos · Answer

Since we're given some solid restrictions on what x and y could be, picking numbers is a quick and easy strategy.

x>y>1, and x and y are integers. Let's try x=3 and y=2. So z=x/y = 3/2

Looking at statements I and II, we can see that they are mutually exclusive. z cannot be both > and < a number at the same time. So right away, we know that either I or II must be true, but never both. So B is out.

Now, using our numbers for x and y, we can set up a little chart to see what happens when we add or subtract 1 from the numerator and denominator.

x-----y-----z-----(x+1)/(y+1)-----(x-1)/(y-1)
3-----2----3/2--------4/3--------------2/1
------------------------<z---------------->z

We can see that when 1 is added to the numerator and denominator, the value decreases, and when it is subtracted, the value increases.

Looking at the statements then, we can see that II and III are true, and I is not.

Answer: C

Now, in general, it is good to know what happens to fractions when you add or subtract a constant from both the numerator and denominator. As long as we're dealing with positive numbers, adding a constant on top and bottom of a fraction will cause the value of the fraction to move closer to 1, and subtracting a constant from the top and bottom a fraction will cause the value of the fraction to get farther from 1. Notice I didn't say increase or decrease, because that will depend on whether the fraction is greater than or less than 1.

Examples:
\(\frac{20-10}{100-10} < \frac{20}{100} < \frac{20+100}{100+100}\)

\(\frac{50+50}{10+50}< \frac{50}{10} < \frac{50-5}{10-5}\)

So in general:

If x>y --> \(\frac{x+a}{y+a} < \frac{x}{y} < \frac{x-a}{y-a}\)

And if x<y --> \(\frac{x-a}{y-a} < \frac{x}{y} < \frac{x+a}{y+a}\)

In our case, x>y, so adding a constant will decrease the fraction (statement III) and subtracting a constant will increase the fraction (statement II).

KSBGC · Answer

i don't understand how 3 one has become true. i used plunging method. i found 3 one is wrong. kindly, make me clear and tell me where make mistake. thanks.

vs224 · Answer

When you plug in number, make sure x > y.

niks18 · Answer

This is a great question to test few properties of a fraction. The properties are - I) If x>y and given a is a positive integer, then \frac{x+a}{y+a}<\frac{x}{y} and \frac{x−a}{y−a}>\frac{x}{y} II) If x\frac{x}{y} and \frac{x−a}{y−a}<\frac{x}{y} So if you are aware of these properties then you will get the answer directly to the question Option C ----------------------------------------------------------------- Now, let's use this question to derive the options Given x>y , multiply both sides by 1 (because in the choice given each fraction is increased/decreased by 1) So we get x*1>y*1 , now add xy to both sides of the inequality =>x+xy>y+xy=>x(y+1)>y(x+1) or \frac{x}{y}>\frac{x+1}{y+1} => z>\frac{x+1}{y+1} . Hence Statement II must be true now multiply the inequality x>y by -1 =>-1*x<-1*y , now add xy to both sides of the inequality xy-xx(y-1)\frac{x}{y}<\frac{x-1}{y-1}=>z<\frac{x-1}{y-1} . Hence Statement III must be true Hi Bunuel , May I request to add these properties to the Number Properties article in GC forum or book because this can be very useful for tricky questions. If its already present there, then kindly ignore.

hassu13 · Answer

If I plug in no`s as x=100 and y=99 then both of these no`s satisfy the inequality as per the question stem but both statement II and III stand out to be incorrect. Also in the qstn its written that both x, y are integers but nothing about z is mentioned. Z can or can`t be an integer. Can someone pl explain. @brunuel

Bunuel · Answer

If x = 100 and y = 99 both II and III ARE correct:

II.  (\frac{100}{99}=1.0101...) < (\frac{(100 − 1)}{(99 − 1)} =1.02...)

III.  (\frac{100}{99}=1.0101...) > (\frac{(100 + 1)}{(99 + 1)}=1.01)

As for your second question, yes z may or may not be an integer but this does not matter, we know that z = x/y and we can substitute this in the options and solve accordingly.

Avinash2303 · Answer

I tried to solve this algebraically

Question says X and Y and Positive + Integer and greater than 1 i.e. least value of Y can be 2 and least of X can be 3

Also z=x/y i.e. Z will always be +ve and will be greater than 1

Also, ZY = X

option I

z (y-1)> (x-1)
Zy -z > (ZY-1)
-Z> -1...
Since Z is greater than 1, negative value of Z cannot be greater than 1. Not true

Note: here though we dont know the value of x,y,z but we can multiply Y-1 both since values are positive and Y-1 is also positive.

OPTION II

By solving equation as mentioned above, result is:

-Z < -1...which is true

OPTION III

Final result is:

Z>1...which is true

Therefore, answer is C.

Posted from my mobile device

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If x and y are positive integers such that x > y > 1 and z=x/y, which

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions