Bunuel
If x and y are integers and 2x–y= 11, then 4x+ y CANNOT be
(A) –5
(B) 1
(C) 13
(D) 17
(E) 55
Solution:Let 4x + y = z. If we add this with 2x - y = 11, we have: 6x = z + 11. Since x is an integer, we see that z + 11 has to be a multiple of 6.
If we multiply 2x - y = 11 by 2, we have 4x - 2y = 22. If we subtract this from 4x + y = z, we have 3y = z - 22. Since y is an integer, we see that z - 22 has to be a multiple of 3.
Now, let’s look at the given answer choices:
A. -5
If z = -5, we see that -5 + 11 = 6 is a multiple of 6 and -5 - 22 = -27 is a multiple of 3. So 4x + y can be -5.
B. 1
If z = 1, we see that 1 + 11 = 12 is a multiple of 6 and 1 - 22 = -21 is a multiple of 3. So 4x + y can be 1.
C. 13
If z = 13, we see that 13 + 11 = 24 is a multiple of 6 and 13 - 22 = -9 is a multiple of 3. So 4x + y can be 13.
D. 17
If z = 17, we see that 17 + 11 = 28 is NOT a multiple of 6. So 4x + y CAN’T be 17.
Alternate Solution:Let’s rewrite the first equation as:
2x - y = 11
2x = 11 + y
4x = 22 + 2y
Now substitute 22 + 2y for 4x into the expression 4x + y, obtaining:
22 + 2y + y
22 + 3y
Let’s set 22 + 3y = q and see if we obtain an integer solution for y as we test each of the answer choices.
Choice A. (q = -5): 22 + 3y = -5 becomes 3y = 27. Thus, y = 9, which is an integer.
Choice B. (q = 1): 22 + 3y = 1 becomes 3y = -21. Thus, y = -7, which is an integer.
Choice C. (q = 13): 22 + 3y = 13 becomes 3y = 9. Thus, y = 3, which is an integer.
Choice D. (q = 17): 22 + 3y = 17 becomes 3y = -5. Thus, y = -5/3, which is NOT an integer.
Choice E. (q = 55): 22 + 3y = 55 becomes 3y = 33. Thus, y = 11, which is an integer.
Thus, the correct answer is D.
Answer: D