AndrewN
Which of the following is not a factor of the solution to the equation \(x-3\sqrt{x}-18=0\)?
(A) 3
(B) 4
(C) 6
(D) 8
(E) 18
Hello, everyone. I came up with this question because I like to encourage creativity in solving quant questions. In addition to the solution outlined above by Arun Kumar of
CrackVerbalGMAT, I thought I would offer two of my own.
Method #1: Factor the expression on the left-hand side just as you would a quadratic.
\((\sqrt{x}-6)(\sqrt{x}+3)=0\)
\(\sqrt{x}-6=0\) or
\(\sqrt{x}+3=0\)
The first will lead to a real solution:
\(\sqrt{x}=6\)
\(x=36\)
The second will lead to an extraneous solution, since we cannot invoke the complex
i, and the √ sign indicates the positive square root only:
\(\sqrt{x}=-3\)
Thus,
x must equal 36. Looking at the answer choices, only 8 is not a factor of 36.
The answer must be (D).Method #2: Use logic and work with the answers.
1) We know that x - 3√x has to equal 18, since subtracting 18 leads to 0. We can deduce that
x must be a perfect square, since any other type of number will lead to a non-integer when the square root is taken.
2) Come up with some reasonable targets, starting from 1: 1, 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, 49...
3) Test a reasonable value, knowing that, again, subtracting 18 from x - 3√x will equal 0. How about 16?
\(16-3\sqrt{16}-18=0\)
\(16-3(4)-18=0\)
\(16-12-18=0\)
\(4-18=0\)
\(-14≠0\)
The outcome was too low. Test a higher value instead. Why not 36 this time?
\(36-3\sqrt{36}-18=0\)
\(36-3(6)-18=0\)
\(36-18-18=0\)
\(36-36=0\)
\(0=0\)
This time, we know we have the right value for
x. All we need to do is examine the answers for non-factors of 36.
The answer must be (D).Either method above should lead to the answer in under a minute. I am guessing that Experts such as Arun Kumar could also use the method in the above post to crack this one in under a minute. There you have it: three solutions to a fairly intimidating question.
I hope you had fun with this one. As always, good luck with your studies.
- Andrew