What is the ratio of a to b to c ?

Question

(1)  \frac{c}{a} =\frac{5}{2}  and  b=4a

(2)  ac = 40  and  b=16

smyarga · Answer

(1) Sufficient. we know that  c=5x  and  a=2x  for some number  x . Therefore  b=8x  and the ratio  a:b:c=2x:8x:5x=2:8:5 .

(2) Insufficient. We don't know the ratio  a:c . 
For example  a=4 ,  c=10  or it could be in reverse order  a=10 ,  c=4 .

The answer is A.

Zarrolou · Answer

What is the ratio of a to b to c ?

a/b/c=\frac{a}{bc}

(1)  \frac{c}{a} =\frac{5}{2}  and  b=4a  
 c=5/2a ,  b=4a 
Substitute  \frac{a}{4a*2.5a}=\frac{1}{10a} . It depends on a.
Not sufficient

(2)  ac = 40  and  b=16  
a and c can have many values (2,20 or 4,10) so the ratio in not determined.
Not sufficient

1+2)b=16 a=4 c=10. We know all the numbers, we know also a/b/c
Sufficient

A is not the answer take c=50 a=20 and b= 80 ratio 1/200
take a=8 c=20 b=32 ratio 1/80. I disagree with the OA...

Rock750 · Answer

I don't think that this is correct ?! all we know is the ratio of a to b is a/b .. that's why you must assign a new variable x and refer to it as smyarga did

It is the correct way to do this

Zarrolou · Answer

My point is : the ratio a to b is a division a/b
The ration a to b is 2 means a/b=2
the ration (a to b) to c is also a division (I don't see why it sould not be). That's why I do not agree, maybe I have to review ratios
Look at the real numbers , all respect A.
a=20 , b= 80 c=50 a:b:c=1/200
a=8 , b=32 c=20 a:b:c=1/80

Rock750 · Answer

in your opinion, why should ratio of a to b to c equal to (a to b) to c and not equal to a to (b to c) ? we don't know if the operation "to" is transitive ..

Zarrolou · Answer

I think we are going nowhere here but in my opinion we should not forget the meaning of ratio: it's a division
5:5:5=0.2 is equal to (5:5):5=0,2 and not to 5:(5:5)=5

smyarga · Answer

Zarrolou, in your examples the ratio is the same.
a=20 , b= 80 c=50 a:b:c=20:80:50=2:8:5
a=8 , b=32 c=20 a:b:c=8:32:20=2:8:5
You shouldn't mix them. Here is relative ratio of three numbers together. The ratio of three numbers a:b:c=n:m:k just means that there some integer x such that a=nx, b=mx, c=kx.

Rock750 · Answer

the ratio of 5:5:5 is equal to 1:1:1

Zarrolou · Answer

Oh yeah guys I see your point Program of my day tomorrow: REVIEW RATIOS! :wink:

smyarga · Answer

For example, the ratio of the number of women to the number of men to the number of children is 1 to 2 to 3. 
Your ratio as 1 to 80 is meaningless, because you compare 3 objects and as result have comparison of two objects.

stne · Answer

Hi

I am also having difficulty understanding this one, expressing all in terms of a
we get b=4a
\(c=\frac{5}{2} a\)
then a:b:c

\(\frac{\frac {a}{4a}}{\frac{5a}{2}}\)

\(so if a =1 \to a:b:c = \frac{\frac {1}{4}}{\frac{5}{2}}\)

\(if a = 2 \to a:b:c = \frac{\frac {2}{8}}{5}\)

\(if a=3 \to a:b:c = \frac{\frac {3}{12}}{\frac{15}{2}\)

\(if a=4 \to a:b:c = \frac{\frac {4}{16}}{{10}}\)

so a:b:c differs each time, does it not?

B alone is also insuff.

1+2

a:b:c 4:16:10

similar sum

what-is-the-ratio-of-x-y-z-56282.html#p400899

Can anybody clear this confusion? Thanks.

stunn3r · Answer

st.1

a/c = 2/5, a/b = 1/4. to put these 3 in ratio we've to equate the common thing i.e. a.
it'll become a/c=2/5 and a/b=2/8. << I equated a in both the expression by multiplying and dividing 2 
a:b:c=2:8:5. 
simple.

st.2

It will clearly wont give the desired rsult.

Bunuel · Answer

What is the ratio of a to b to c ?

(1)  \frac{c}{a} =\frac{5}{2}  and  b=4a . From  b=4a , we have the  \frac{a}{b}=\frac{1}{4}=\frac{2}{8} . So, we have that a:c=2:5 and a:b=2:8 --> a:b:c=2:8:5. Sufficient.

(2)  ac = 40  and  b=16 . Not sufficient.

Answer: A.

As for your solution: the ratio is the same! You have a:b:c = a:4a:(2.5a) --> a reduces: a:b:c = 1:4:(2.5), which is the same ratio as a:b:c = 2:8:5 = 4:16:10 = 8:32:20 ...

Hope it's clear.

stne · Answer

First of all thank you members,
But little confusion still remains, as long as I see this sum in isolation everything is clear but when I try and relate this sum to this sum given below I get a bit confused.

What is the ratio of x:y:z? (what-is-the-ratio-of-x-y-z-56282.html#p400899 )

(1) xy = 14
(2) yz = 21

now in this sum individually obviously both are insufficient
but when we take them together, expressing everything in terms of y

\(x = \frac {14}{y}\)
\(z =\frac {21}{y}\)

\(so \,x:y:z = \frac {\frac{\frac{14}{y}}{y}}{\frac{21}{y}}\)

\(so \, for \, Y=1 \to x:y:z =\frac {\frac{14}{1}}{21}\)

and
\(for \, Y=7 \to x:y:z =\frac {\frac{2}{7}}{3}\)

now using the same logic as above where we said "a reduces" and said that the ratio remains the same, can't we say in this sum too that ( x:y:z ) "Y reduces" hence 1+2 is sufficient to answer the ratio of x:y:z ?

if in a:b:c sum we say " as a:b:c = 2:8:5 = 4:16:10 = 8:32:20 ... " meaning in all the cases ratio is same

why in x:y:z = 14:1:21 and x:y:z = 2:7:3 , we are taking ratio to be different? shouldn't the ratio be same whether x:y:z= 14:1:21 or x:y:z = 2:7:3

we can say Y can be reduced and that 14:1:21 is the same as 2:7:3 answer should be C in this x:y:z sum, still here the answer is E. ?? Am I messing up something? Thanks.

Edit: my bad didn't see that 14:1:21 cannot be reduced to 2:7:3 so of course the answer is E

stunn3r · Answer

Hey, if you havent checked my post .. check it .. just above bunuel's post >> what-is-the-ratio-of-a-to-b-to-c-151800.html#p1240411 we have to equate the common term in two ratios to get a three no. ratio ... like a/b=1/2 and a/c=3/2 . here common term is a. After equating a .. the expressions will be a/b=3/6 and a/c=3/2 .. here I made a equal in both the expressions. hence a:b:c=3:6:2. In the question you posted there is no way you can do this. Hence answer is E. got it ?

stne · Answer

@stunn3r

Thank you, equating the common variable seems to make sense , doing it my way where I was expressing everything in terms of a single variable , does not seem to work here. Thank you

mtk10 · Answer

Only Statement 1 allows us to quantify a relationship between three variables.

Equation 1: a = 2c/5 
Equation 2: a= b/4

Hence Sufficient
Statement 2 is not sufficient because we cannot equate.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

What is the ratio of a to b to c ?

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

What is the ratio of a to b to c ?

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards