Let’s define:
Let M = number of students in the math club
Let S = number of students in the science club
Let B = number of students who belong to both clubs
Since some students may be in both clubs, this creates overlap in the pool.
Let:
A = number of students only in math club
C = number of students only in science club
So:
M=A+B
S=C+B
A valid team = one person from math club, one from science club
So total possible teams = (A+B)(C+B)
We are to find the number of teams where at least one student belongs to both clubs.
This means:
Total teams – teams where neither student is in both clubs
So the key idea is:
Answer = Total teams – Teams where neither student is in both clubs
Let’s evaluate each statement now.
Statement (1):The number of teams where neither student belongs to both clubs is 9.
So:
Teams with neither in both clubs = A×C=9
Total teams = (A+B)(C+B)
Therefore, teams with at least one student in both clubs = (A+B)(C+B)−A⋅C
But we only know A⋅C=9.
We don’t know
A+B, C+B, or even B.
We cannot determine the exact number of teams with at least one student in both clubs.
So, Statement (1) alone is insufficient.Statement (2):The number of teams where both students belong to both clubs is 6.
That means:
We are selecting one student from math club, and one from science club,
and both selected students are from the group of B students (those in both clubs).
So number of such teams = B×B=B^2=6
=> B=√6
, which is not an integer
But B must be an integer, since it counts students.
So this implies some logical error in assuming
B×B=6.
Wait — rereading: in this setup, we select two students:
One from the math club
One from the science club
So to get both students to be from the "both clubs" group, we must choose:
a student from the math club who is also in science, and
a student from the science club who is also in math
So valid such pairs = number of ways to pick 1 student from B (for math club)
and 1 student from B (for science club):
So still =
B×B=B^2 =6 → again
B = √6 , not possible.
Hence, this statement gives an invalid or inconsistent scenario.
So Statement (2) is invalid — the number of teams with both students in both clubs cannot be 6 unless B is irrational, which is not possible.
So Statement (2) is not valid => Cannot be used.Combining (1) and (2):
We already saw (2) is invalid (requires non-integer count of students).
So combining them doesn’t help.
Only Statement (1) is valid, but insufficient.
So, the correct answer is: E. Statements (1) and (2) together are not sufficient.
Answer: E