You've got a shot at top 10 schools & for sure, although it probably makes sense to apply top 15 just to round things out. Your GMAT looks great as does your GPA & work experience. If you think you can improve your GMAT score go for it, but a 750 is great as is.
Insurance is not all that common among b-school candidates, which is a good thing, and it sounds like you've had some meaningful leadership experience and accomplishments that you can speak to in your essays. You've also got solid extracurriculars and it sounds like you've shown consistency there. So lots of good news in terms of your candidacy.
So what are your challenges? It is a bit tough as a white male -- you've got to work harder to differentiate yourself and show how you'll uniquely contribute to the diversity of their class mix. In addition to that, both consulting & IB are fairly common goals. That's not to say you shouldn't pursue one of them, but it does mean there's even more need to make yourself stand out via other aspects of your application.
In terms of HOW to make yourself stand out, there's no formula per se (if there were it wouldn't be unique, right?) but there are all sorts of options. You can differentiate yourself via your work experience (leadership examples might be promising since you've had more leadership experience than the average candidate). Showing that you've had really significant impact at work also sets you up to show how you plan to have impact at b-school and beyond in your post-MBA goals. Speaking of which, the goals you choose & how you talk about them are critical since your whole argument for why you need the MBA hinges on those. You want to have a strong argument not only for what exactly you plan to accomplish in your goals (what types of problems do you want to help solve? What types of opportunities do you want to take advantage of?) but also WHY those are your goals. And then of course you want to be ready to articulate a strong argument for the specific skill gaps you need to fill in b-school to achieve those goals. It might be worth also considering insurance as a post-MBA goal. You've got the foundation in it & it's not a common goal. If you could outline a vision for how you'd plan to really impact the industry in a positive way that could be a differentiator. Like I said though, consulting or IB could work as well, but they are more common so you'll want to really be ready to make a strong argument for why these are your goals to help set you apart from the crowd.
The essays at top schools are also becoming increasingly personal and schools want to know not just what you've accomplished professionally but also who you are as a person. So there's room to differentiate yourself there as well.
Long story short, you've got a great foundation & your numbers look good as well. You just want to be sure to think about how to stand out from the crowd of equally qualified candidates.
Definitely reach out to us if you'd like to set up a free consultation with one of our MBA consultants. This is exactly the type of work we help our clients with and a consultant could go into more detail with you one on one. If that's of interest, reach out to Claudia at
[email protected]!