Congrats on your acceptances thus far! Have you looked at Kelley Direct from the IU Kelley School of Business (ranked #1 online program by U.S. News 2 years in a row)? I'm currently getting my MBA there, and as of last year I also work for the program.
Our program may enable you to get the best of both worlds. We just announced our MS in Entrepreneurship & Innovation and will be starting classes this Fall. If you're not ready to pursue just entrepreneurship, you can add it onto our MBA and earn a dual-degree with just 4 additional classes.
Our online programs were attracting mostly students in your situation: they want to move up in their current company, but want a reputable degree that will help them advance in the future. Now, about 40% of our students want to switch careers, companies or industries. Our Graduate Career Services has adapted to these new demands by adding additional resources including staff, a career development program for all incoming students and career events specifically for online students. Last week we hosted an online networking event for students interested in consulting that enabled students to meet and make connections with consultants from 6 different firms.
Kelley has the largest business school network in the world (we just passed 100,000 living alumni last year), which means you should be able to find connections wherever you want to go after earning your MBA. With your company's reimbursement and a great GMAT score, you may not have to pay much if anything at all for our MBA - and probably get two degrees for less than the cost of your other options.
PM me if you would like to learn more. Based on the schools you're looking at I would guess you're on the east coast? We have an in-person networking event coming up in D.C. (March 18) and a special event just for prospective students in Bloomington, IN the weekend of March 27-28. I highly recommend attending that on-campus event!