If a^5*b^6*c^7 0, is a*b^3*c^5

Question

If a^{5}b^{6}c^{7} > 0 , is ab^{3}c^{5} <0 ? (1) b < 0 (2) c > 0 Project DS Butler Data Sufficiency (DS3) For DS butler Questions Click Here

Saraskarki · Answer

Question states ac>0 as b with an even power is always positive
So for ab^3c^5<0 we just need to find whether b is positive
1) states what is required i.e b <0 sufficient
2) no info about b only states c >0 and eventually a>0
Ans A

Posted from my mobile device

p05eid0n · Answer

we know that even powers is always positive - so b^6 is positive. 
since the whole number is positive, a^5 and c^7 are also positive, implying that a and c are of same sign. i.e. ac>0

(1) b < 0

In our required number, the number changed to odd power of b, if this is the case ab^3c^5 will be negative
so statement 1 is enough

(2) c > 0

If c is greater than 0, then a is greater than 0. but we don't know anything about the sign of b. 
so Statement 2 is insufficient.

IMO A

AjitJangale · Answer

From given data it is clear that a and c should be either positive or negative. Means both have same sign. So there product is always positive. Hence to get our answer we only need to know sign of b.

(1) b < 0
Now we know b is negative and product is less than 0.

Sufficient

(2) c > 0
We don't know value of b.

Insufficient.

IMO Answer is A.

Nevernevergiveup · Answer

If a^{5}b^{6}c^{7} > 0 , is ab^{3}c^{5} <0 ? let us split LHS term in terms of what we want a^{5}b^{6}c^{7} > 0 , ~( ab^{3}c^{5} )*( a^{4}b^{3}c^{2})>0 now if the part from what is asked is taken in to consideration a & c have even powers so result will be positive but need sign of b (1) b < 0 this makes it clear that ( a^{4}b^{3}c^{2})<0 so as product is positive ab^{3}c^{5} <0 SUFFICIENT (2) c > 0 if we place this in a^{5}b^{6}c^{7} > 0 we can conclude a>0 now with a,c>0 we still need b sign so this doesn't help INSUFFICIENT A is the answer

aviddd · Answer

a^5*b^6*c^7>0

b^6 will always be positive. This means a and c both are positive or both are negative. Either ways a*c > 0.

So, to determine if a*b^3*c^5 < 0, all we need to know is if b<0. because a*c^5 will always be positive.

1. b<0. Sufficient.
2. c> 0. This only tells us a is also >0. But, no mention of b. Insufficient.

Answer: A

KaramveerBakshi · Answer

If a^5*b^6*c^7 > 0
That means a,c +ve and b is +ve or -ve. --- (A)
OR
That means a,c -ve and b is +ve or -ve. --- (B)

Is a*b^3*c^5< 0? --- (C)
To find we need to find b or both a and c together.

Statements:

(1) b<0
For either (A) or (B), the expression (C) would depend on b.
Since b<0, (C) would be negative.
Sufficient.

(2) c>0
We don't know b. If c>0 that means a>0 but depending on b the value of (C) would change.
Insufficient.

Hence, the answer is Option (A).

sambitspm · Answer

Kindly see the attachment. Just go with the statement at hand. Then see the options.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If a^5b^6c^7 > 0, is ab^3c^5 <0 ? (1) b < 0 (2) c > 0

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

If a^5*b^6*c^7 > 0, is a*b^3*c^5 <0 ? (1) b < 0 (2) c > 0