Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004 documentary "The Agronomist" is both a

Question

Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004  documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative  visit with one of its most colorful citizens

A. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative
B. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative
C. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative
D. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a very provocative
E. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

OFFICIAL EXPLANATION

Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004  documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative  visit with one of its most colorful citizens

A. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative

This answer choice is grammatically incorrect. The correct idiom is  both A and B .

B. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative

This answer choice repeats the original mistake. The correct idiom is  both A and B .

In addition, this answer choice creates a Subject Verb Agreement mistake by replacing the singular verb  is  with the plural form  are .

C. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative

While this answer choice corrects the original mistake, it creates a Subject Verb Agreement mistake by replacing the singular verb  is  with the plural form  are .

D. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a very provocative

While this answer choice corrects the original mistake, it changes the meaning of the original sentence by adding the word  very .

E. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative

CORRECT

Franals2 · Answer

The documentary needs "is" and "as well" is badly placed to describe two characteristics, we need "and". IMO E

zhanbo · Answer

My answer is (E) . It took me 58 seconds. (A) "Both" should be paired with "And“, not "As well as". (B) The sentence's subject (Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004 documentary "The Agronomist") is singular. (C) See above. (DE) do not contain evident issues. The only difference between (D) and (E) are the "very" in "D". I have to say that an actual GMAT question would not present such a split. But we can come up with several reasons against the use of "very". <1> "very" is a hugely overused word. To the untrained ears, "very provocative" and "provocative" invoke similar emotional response. In that case, "very" is redundant. <2> To be parallel with “a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past“, in which no adverb is used to emphasize intensity of the speedy crash course or the tumultuous past, we may get the hint and be reluctant to throw in ”very“. Ultimately, the sentence writer may claim that (D) can be easily eliminated because (A) does not use "very". Such argument should be rejected though because each version should be evaluated independently. (A) does not necessarily present a view that matches the so-called intended meaning.

sivatx2 · Answer

A. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past  as well as  a provocative 
 both X and Y is the correct idiom. Eliminate

B. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past  as well as  a provocative 
 both X and Y is the correct idiom. Eliminate

C.  documentary  "The Agronomist"  are  both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative 
 documentary is singular and don't agree with linking verb 'are'. Eliminate

D. documentary "The Agronomist" is both  a crash course  in the nation's tumultuous past and  a very provocative  
 'a crash course' is not parallel with 'a very provocative'. Eliminate

E. documentary "The Agronomist" is both  a crash course  in the nation's tumultuous past and  a provocative  
 Fixes all the issues in the earlier options and grammatically correct.
 
 So E is the best answer choice.

100mitra · Answer

Correct Option E

Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004  documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative  visit with one of its most colorful citizens

Sentence Exam on :
- SV Agreement 
- Idiom Both X and Y

both X and Y  is parallel structure, and both elements are regarded equally. 
 X as well as Y  X is the main focus and Y is an afterthought, of secondary importance
they are definitely not presented rhetorically as equals. 
This second structure is NOT parallelism.

Both  X and Y  - has to be parallel and equally important 
X = a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past
Y = a provocative visit with one of its most colorful citizens

Eliminate A, and B , based on above knowledge.

A. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative   - Wrong  
B. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative   - Wrong

Eliminate C - SV Agreement flaw  
"The Agronomist" - Singular and verb used "are"
C. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative   - Wrong

Eliminate D - Parallelism flaw  and use of very adjective before provocative 
D. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a very provocative   - Wrong

Correct Answer E   
E. documentary  "The Agronomist" is  both 
- a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and 
- a provocative

aishu0091 · Answer

Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004 documentary  "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative  visit with one of its most colorful citizens

A. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative - the structure of the 'idiom' (not sure if its an idiom lol) - both x... And Y,  here its both... as well as.. - hence eliminated. 
B. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative - the subject is singular and hence 'is' is the appropriate verb  and not 'are', - hence eliminated.  
C. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative- the subject is singular and hence 'is' is the appropriate verb  and not 'are', - hence eliminated . 
D. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a very provocative - Perfect but the word ' Very' changes the meaning of the sentence.  - hence eliminated.
E. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative -  Looks perfect!

Vatsal7794 · Answer

It took me 44secs to solve

Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004 documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative visit with one of its most colorful citizens

A. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative - Idiom is Both X and Y
B. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past as well as a provocative - SV ERROR 
C. documentary "The Agronomist" are both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative - SV ERROR
D. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a very provocative - Use of word "very" is redundant
E. documentary "The Agronomist" is both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative - Correct

Posted from my mobile device

VelvetThunder · Answer

Not clear as to why "is" is correct here? shouldn't "BOTH" be preceded by "are" since "both" is plural?

ExpertsGlobal5 · Answer

Hello  VelvetThunder ,

We hope this finds you well.

Having gone through the question and your query, we believe we can resolve your doubt.

You are correct that "both a crash course in the nation's tumultuous past and a provocative visit" is a plural noun phrase, however, this phrase is the object of the sentence, not the subject. The subject of the sentence - the "doer" of the action "is" - is the action of "Watching", which is singular.

We hope this helps.
All the best!
Experts' Global Team

Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004 documentary "The Agronomist" is both a

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

Watching Jonathan Demme's 2004 documentary "The Agronomist" is both a

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards