What is the value of m + n ? (1) mn = -8 (2) -2m = n

Question

What is the value of m + n ?

(1) mn = -8
(2) -2m = n

argerniki · Answer

Statement 1: 
mn = -8

Because m & n do not have to be integers, we have an infinite number of possible solutions.
To show only 2 possible solutions:
m = 8, n = -1 --> m + n = 7
m = 16, n = -0,5 --> m + n = 15,5

Two different solutions, therefore
INSUFF

Statement 2: 
-2m = n

No actual values, only the relationship between m & n, so the values could be anything:
m = 1, n = -2 --> m +n = -1
m = 100, n = -200 --> m + n = -100

Two different solutions, therefore
INSUFF

Statements 1 & 2 combined: 
It follows from Statement 2 that -2m = n
Possible factor-pairs of -8 (Statement 1), that fulfill this requirement, are: -2 & 4 and 2 & -4
Check m + n for both possibilities:

-2 + 4 = 2
2 + -4 = -2

Two different solutions, therefore INSUFF

Answer E

chetan2u · Answer

m and n can be anything: positive or negative, integer or fraction. 
If you get a similar question in actuals, just skip individual statements and look if you can get anything when combined.

Combined
Substitute n=-2m in mn=-8.
m(-2m)=-8
 m^2=4

m can be 2 or -2, respective value of n can be -4 and 4.
m+n can be 2-4 or -2+4
Different answers

E

Bunuel · Answer

MAGOOSH OFFICIAL SOLUTION There’s no obviously useful way to rephrase the question, so we’ll probably need to solve for m and n and then add the values together. Keep an eye open, though, for an opportunity to solve for the sum m + n directly. Statement (1) doesn’t allow any good method of breaking up the single term mn, so will not yield a value for m, n, or m + n. Eliminate A and D. Was that too fast? Suppose that it wasn’t obvious to you that the statement “doesn’t allow any good method of breaking up the single term mn.” What could you do? You could either attempt to isolate the expression for which you’re solving or test values. Let’s try the latter. To test values for Statement (1) make a simple table. Use this table to ask, “Does every pair of values legal for Statement (1) yield the same answer to our question, that is the same value for m + n?” My table begins with a pair of values m and n whose product is -8, and adds a third column for the sum of those values. If the sum is the same for every row, then the statement is sufficient to answer the question, or we’ve just overlooked a counterexample. https://gmatclub.com/forum/download/file.php?id=60704 Since different values consistent with Statement (1) yield different answers to our question, (1) is not sufficient. Eliminate A and D. We could use a similar method with Statement (2), but it’s probably easier in this case to isolate the expression for which we’re solving. -2m = n Add m to each side to get m+n on the right-hand side of the equation. -m = m + n Since the expression m + n is not equal to a unique constant, unless we’ve missed some more fruitful way to manipulate this equation, Statement (2) doesn’t answer the question. Eliminate B. Now consider the two statements together. Since Statement (1) is not linear, even together the two statements probably won’t yield a unique constant solution. There are a couple of exceptional cases though, so let’s solve this system of equations. Since (2) gives us n in terms of m, it makes solving by substitution pretty manageable. Substitute -2m for n in (1). m(-2m) = -8 Clear the parentheses. -2m^2 = -8 Divide each side by -2. m^2 = 4 Take the square root of each side of the equation. m = +/-2 That’s two possible solutions, so even together (1) and (2) are not sufficient to solve for m. It might occur to you that we’re after the sum m + n not just after m. If you want to be extra-careful, substitute the two possible values for m into either of the given equations and see whether they yield the same value for m + n. They do not. The correct answer is E. efq5a6_img1a.png

What is the value of m + n ? (1) mn = -8 (2) -2m = n

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards