Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Director
Joined: 25 Oct 2008
Posts: 580
Location: Kolkata,India

A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 01:14
3
This post received KUDOS
24
This post was BOOKMARKED
Question Stats:
70% (01:24) correct 30% (01:53) wrong based on 306 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one, every ball is selected at random without replacement. What is the probability that the fourth ball selected is black? A. 1/4 B. 1/2 C. 1/2 D. 5/8 E. 2/3
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________
http://gmatclub.com/forum/countdownbeginshasended8548340.html#p649902



Manager
Joined: 11 Sep 2009
Posts: 129

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 01:34
6
This post received KUDOS
3
This post was BOOKMARKED
The answer should be C: 5/8.
The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion.



Intern
Joined: 22 Sep 2009
Posts: 6

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 03:54
AKProdigy87, that's correct but I wonder how many people would be quick to realize that the probability is that same as in the first draw . The other route of doing a tree diagram takes 4 mins at least !



Director
Joined: 01 Jan 2008
Posts: 605

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 05:33
1
This post received KUDOS
jeffm wrote: AKProdigy87, that's correct but I wonder how many people would be quick to realize that the probability is that same as in the first draw . It's very intuitive. A formal proof would involve noticing that for each sequence of 4 balls that get pulled out (x1,x2,x3,x4) there is a corresponding sequence (x4,x2,x3,x1) that can be pull out with the same probability (we pull out 4 balls and then order them in a sequence) > Prob(x4=black) = Prob(x1=black).



Manager
Joined: 14 Dec 2008
Posts: 137

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 11:40
AKP : The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion.
question: will this hold for both with replacement and without replacement?



Manager
Joined: 11 Sep 2009
Posts: 129

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 12:41
2
This post received KUDOS
manojgmat wrote: AKP : The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion.
question: will this hold for both with replacement and without replacement? With replacement, it's pretty obvious that the probability will hold constant. Without replacement, it's a bit harder to see. Imagine if you had 3 balls (2 black, 1 yellow). What's the probability you draw a black ball on the 3rd draw? It will be 2/3. The reason is that 2/3 of the time, there will be black ball left. So the expected value of the colour of the third ball is 2/3 Black and 1/3 Yellow. The same principle applies to a 4th draw of 8 balls.



Director
Status: Apply  Last Chance
Affiliations: IIT, Purdue, PhD, TauBetaPi
Joined: 18 Jul 2010
Posts: 664
Schools: Wharton, Sloan, Chicago, Haas
WE 1: 8 years in Oil&Gas

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Aug 2010, 18:35
AKProdigy87 wrote: manojgmat wrote: AKP : The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion.
question: will this hold for both with replacement and without replacement? With replacement, it's pretty obvious that the probability will hold constant. Without replacement, it's a bit harder to see. Imagine if you had 3 balls (2 black, 1 yellow). What's the probability you draw a black ball on the 3rd draw? It will be 2/3. The reason is that 2/3 of the time, there will be black ball left. So the expected value of the colour of the third ball is 2/3 Black and 1/3 Yellow. The same principle applies to a 4th draw of 8 balls. So you are saying it does not matter if with or without replacement? I mean the probablity of drawing a ball from a mixture of colored balls in the nth drawing is simply the fraction of that color?
_________________
Consider kudos, they are good for health



Manager
Joined: 18 Oct 2010
Posts: 76

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Jun 2012, 01:56
tejal777 wrote: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one, every ball is selected at random without replacement. What is the probability that the fourth ball selected is black? 1/4 1/2 1/2 5/8 2/3 3/4 Can some explain this concept please : How does the fourth ball does not depend of the first 3 balls ? if the first 3 are yellow then the 4 one has to be black , right? on the other hand if we have BBB or BYB then the fourth one can be Y so it looks like there is some dependence on the first 3 balls . can some one please explain this with clear concept. Highly appreciated .



Current Student
Joined: 29 Mar 2012
Posts: 319
Location: India
GMAT 1: 640 Q50 V26 GMAT 2: 660 Q50 V28 GMAT 3: 730 Q50 V38

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Jun 2012, 03:14
Hi,
My approach,
_ _ _ _ (representing 4 draw) total no. of ways in which 4 balls can be drawn = 8P4 _ _ _ B (when 4th ball is black) = 7P4
Thus probability of 4th ball being black = 7P4 / 8P4 =1/8 Now, I believe since 5 black balls are there, answer would be 5/8 but all black balls being same, so the answer should be 1/8.
Any comments?
Regards,



Manager
Joined: 12 May 2012
Posts: 78
Location: India
Concentration: General Management, Operations
GMAT 1: 650 Q51 V25 GMAT 2: 730 Q50 V38
GPA: 4
WE: General Management (Transportation)

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Jun 2012, 03:37
10
This post received KUDOS
4
This post was BOOKMARKED
AKProdigy87 wrote: The answer should be C: 5/8.
The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion. That was simply amazing My complicated version of your simple approach Let the 5 black balls be BBBBB and 3 Red Balls be RRR They can be arranged in 8 slots _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in (8!)/ (5!x3!) If the fourth slot is Black ball then the arrangement will be to fill _ _ _ B _ _ _ _ we have 7 slots and 4 Black (BBBB) and 3 Red (RRR) They can be arranged in (7!)/ (4!x3!) Hence required probability = [(7!)/ (4!x3!)] / [(8!)/ (5!x3!)] Ans = 5/8
Last edited by manulath on 07 Jun 2012, 04:11, edited 1 time in total.



Senior Manager
Joined: 27 May 2012
Posts: 455

Re: 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Jun 2012, 04:08
manulath wrote: AKProdigy87 wrote: The answer should be C: 5/8.
The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion. That was simply amazing My complicated version of your simple approach Let the 5 black balls be BBBBB and 3 Red Balls be RRR They can be arranged in 8 slots _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in (8!)/ (5!x3!) If the fourth slot is Black ball then the arrangement will be to fill _ _ _ B _ _ _ _ we have 7 slots and 4 Black (BBBB) and 3 Red (RRR) They can be arranged in (7!)/ (4!x3!) Hence required probability = [(8!)/ (5!x3!)]/[(7!)/ (4!x3!)] Ans = 5/8 @ manunath +1 [(7!)/ (4!x3!)] / [(8!)/ (5!x3!)] = 5/8
_________________
 Stne



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 44320

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one [#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Jun 2012, 12:36
2
This post received KUDOS
Expert's post
2
This post was BOOKMARKED



Intern
Joined: 06 May 2013
Posts: 9

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one [#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Jun 2013, 13:54
Bunuel, I don't get it even after reading the explanation. Aren't we reducing the total number of balls with each drawing?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 44320

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one [#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Jun 2013, 13:58



Director
Joined: 17 Dec 2012
Posts: 635
Location: India

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one [#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Jun 2013, 19:19
3
This post received KUDOS
Expert's post
1
This post was BOOKMARKED
sgclub wrote: Bunuel, I don't get it even after reading the explanation. Aren't we reducing the total number of balls with each drawing? Consider 2 black balls and 1 white ball At the first draw, probability that the ball is black is 2/3 Once a ball is removed, remaining balls may be 1b and 1W, 1b and 1W or 2b At the second draw probability that the ball is black is, 1/3*1/2 + 1/3*1/2 + 1/3*1 = 2/3 We can see that the probability does not change even without replacement.
_________________
Srinivasan Vaidyaraman Sravna http://www.sravnatestprep.com/courses.php
Premium Material Standardized Approaches



Manager
Joined: 23 Sep 2015
Posts: 90
Concentration: General Management, Finance
GMAT 1: 680 Q46 V38 GMAT 2: 690 Q47 V38
GPA: 3.5

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one [#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Nov 2015, 21:09
I simply calculated the total possibilities 8!/3!5! = 56
Then fixed the 4th position as Black, then calculated the possibilities  7!/3!4! = 35
therefore 35/56 = 5/8



Manager
Joined: 27 Jan 2016
Posts: 149

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one [#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Oct 2017, 00:10
1
This post was BOOKMARKED
SravnaTestPrep wrote: sgclub wrote: Bunuel, I don't get it even after reading the explanation. Aren't we reducing the total number of balls with each drawing? Consider 2 black balls and 1 white ball At the first draw, probability that the ball is black is 2/3 Once a ball is removed, remaining balls may be 1b and 1W, 1b and 1W or 2b At the second draw probability that the ball is black is, 1/3*1/2 + 1/3*1/2 + 1/3*1 = 2/3 We can see that the probability does not change even without replacement. This explanation is pretty much clear. I was grappling with confusion, as I could not figure out why the probability remains the same even without replacement. Thanks a lot




Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
11 Oct 2017, 00:10






