Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Senior Manager
Joined: 25 Oct 2008
Posts: 459
Location: Kolkata,India

A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 01:14
Question Stats:
73% (01:17) correct 27% (02:18) wrong based on 395 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one, every ball is selected at random without replacement. What is the probability that the fourth ball selected is black? A. 1/4 B. 1/2 C. 5/8 D. 2/3 E. 3/4
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________
http://gmatclub.com/forum/countdownbeginshasended8548340.html#p649902




Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 58427

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Feb 2010, 05:56
dmetla wrote: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one, every ball is selected at random without replacement. What is the probability that the fourth ball selected is black? The initial probability of drawing black ball is 5/8. Without knowing the other results, the probability of drawing black ball will not change for ANY successive drawing: second, third, fourth... The same for yellow ball probability of drawing yellow ball is 3/8, the probability that 8th ball drawn is yellow is still 3/8. There is simply no reason to believe WHY is any drawing different from another (provided we don't know the other results). Hope it's clear.
_________________




Manager
Joined: 29 Nov 2009
Posts: 95
Location: United States

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Feb 2010, 10:38
I thought of it this way:
All possibilities with fourth ball fixed as black XXXBXXXX
7 spots, three filled by yellow, four filled by black: (7!)/(3!*4!) = 35
All total possibilities of arranging 3 yellow and 5 black balls: (8!)/(3!*5!) = 56
35/56 = 5/8




Manager
Joined: 11 Sep 2009
Posts: 115

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 01:34
The answer should be C: 5/8.
The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion.



Intern
Joined: 22 Sep 2009
Posts: 5

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 03:54
AKProdigy87, that's correct but I wonder how many people would be quick to realize that the probability is that same as in the first draw . The other route of doing a tree diagram takes 4 mins at least !



Senior Manager
Joined: 01 Jan 2008
Posts: 458

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 05:33
jeffm wrote: AKProdigy87, that's correct but I wonder how many people would be quick to realize that the probability is that same as in the first draw . It's very intuitive. A formal proof would involve noticing that for each sequence of 4 balls that get pulled out (x1,x2,x3,x4) there is a corresponding sequence (x4,x2,x3,x1) that can be pull out with the same probability (we pull out 4 balls and then order them in a sequence) > Prob(x4=black) = Prob(x1=black).



Manager
Joined: 14 Dec 2008
Posts: 93

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 11:40
AKP : The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion.
question: will this hold for both with replacement and without replacement?



Manager
Joined: 11 Sep 2009
Posts: 115

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Sep 2009, 12:41
manojgmat wrote: AKP : The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion.
question: will this hold for both with replacement and without replacement? With replacement, it's pretty obvious that the probability will hold constant. Without replacement, it's a bit harder to see. Imagine if you had 3 balls (2 black, 1 yellow). What's the probability you draw a black ball on the 3rd draw? It will be 2/3. The reason is that 2/3 of the time, there will be black ball left. So the expected value of the colour of the third ball is 2/3 Black and 1/3 Yellow. The same principle applies to a 4th draw of 8 balls.



Manager
Joined: 26 May 2005
Posts: 159

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Feb 2010, 23:54
3 yellow 5 black possible outcomes for the first 3 tries and 4th is black yyyb  3/8 * 2/7 * 1/6 * 5/5 = 30/(8*7*6*5) yybb  3/8 * 2/7 * 5/6 * 4/5 = 120/(8*7*6*5) ybyb  3/8 * 5/7 * 2/6 * 4/5 = 120/(8*7*6*5) ybbb 3/8 * 5/7 * 4/6 * 3/5 = 180/(8*7*6*5) bbbb  5/8 * 4/7 * 3/6 * 2/5 = 120/(8*7*6*5) bbyb  5/8 * 4/7 * 3/6 * 3/5 = 180/(8*7*6*5) bybb  5/8 * 3/7 * 4/6 * 3/5 = 180/(8*7*6*5) byyb  5/8 * 3/7 * 2/6 * 4/5 = 120/(8*7*6*5)
total = 1050/(8*7*6*5)= 5/8



Senior Manager
Joined: 21 Jul 2009
Posts: 296
Schools: LBS, INSEAD, IMD, ISB  Anything with just 1 yr program.

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Feb 2010, 12:35
Bunuel wrote: The initial probability of drawing black ball is 5/8. Without knowing the other results, the probability of drawing black ball will not change for ANY successive drawing: second, third, fourth... The same for yellow ball probability of drawing yellow ball is 3/8, the probability that 8th ball drawn is yellow is still 3/8. There is simply no reason to believe WHY is any drawing different from another (provided we don't know the other results).
Hope it's clear. Selected balls aren't replaced. The first ball to be black is 5/8 and to be yellow is 3/8. But, for the second ball selected to be black, it could still be 5/7 or 4/7. So, for the probability of third ball to be black, the first two could be black, or just one, or none could be black at all. Going by this counting technique..., I don't see how to calculate the fourth ball's probability to be black.
_________________
I am AWESOME and it's gonna be LEGENDARY!!!



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 58427

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Feb 2010, 12:57
BarneyStinson wrote: Bunuel wrote: The initial probability of drawing black ball is 5/8. Without knowing the other results, the probability of drawing black ball will not change for ANY successive drawing: second, third, fourth... The same for yellow ball probability of drawing yellow ball is 3/8, the probability that 8th ball drawn is yellow is still 3/8. There is simply no reason to believe WHY is any drawing different from another (provided we don't know the other results).
Hope it's clear. Selected balls aren't replaced. The first ball to be black is 5/8 and to be yellow is 3/8. But, for the second ball selected to be black, it could still be 5/7 or 4/7. So, for the probability of third ball to be black, the first two could be black, or just one, or none could be black at all. Going by this counting technique..., I don't see how to calculate the fourth ball's probability to be black. Consider this: there are 8 cards, 5 spades, 3 hearts. What is the probability that the first card you pick will be spade? Clearly 5/8. Now next question, suppose I throw away three cards at random, not telling you which cards I thrown away. What is the probability NOW that you pick a spade out of 5 remaining cards? I've just reduced the sample from which you pick, but does the probability changed? WHY should it change? Another question, the same cards 5 spades and 3 hearts: I say that you can pick one card but only out of randomly selected 5 cards. What is the probability that the card you pick will be spade? I think there is no difference in ALL above cases and the probability will remain 5/8. If it changed, increased (or decreased), it would mean that the probability of picking heart on the other hand decreased (or increased). Why would it?
_________________



Manager
Joined: 01 Feb 2010
Posts: 178

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Feb 2010, 11:19
Bunuel wrote: BarneyStinson wrote: Bunuel wrote: The initial probability of drawing black ball is 5/8. Without knowing the other results, the probability of drawing black ball will not change for ANY successive drawing: second, third, fourth... The same for yellow ball probability of drawing yellow ball is 3/8, the probability that 8th ball drawn is yellow is still 3/8. There is simply no reason to believe WHY is any drawing different from another (provided we don't know the other results).
Hope it's clear. Selected balls aren't replaced. The first ball to be black is 5/8 and to be yellow is 3/8. But, for the second ball selected to be black, it could still be 5/7 or 4/7. So, for the probability of third ball to be black, the first two could be black, or just one, or none could be black at all. Going by this counting technique..., I don't see how to calculate the fourth ball's probability to be black. Consider this: there are 8 cards, 5 spades, 3 hearts. What is the probability that the first card you pick will be spade? Clearly 5/8. Now next question, suppose I throw away three cards at random, not telling you which cards I thrown away. What is the probability NOW that you pick a spade out of 5 remaining cards? I've just reduced the sample from which you pick, but does the probability changed? WHY should it change? Another question, the same cards 5 spades and 3 hearts: I say that you can pick one card but only out of randomly selected 5 cards. What is the probability that the card you pick will be spade? I think there is no difference in ALL above cases and the probability will remain 5/8. If it changed, increased (or decreased), it would mean that the probability of picking heart on the other hand decreased (or increased). Why would it? Nice explanation didn't thought after reading questin that it was so simple.



Manager
Joined: 12 May 2012
Posts: 67
Location: India
Concentration: General Management, Operations
GMAT 1: 650 Q51 V25 GMAT 2: 730 Q50 V38
GPA: 4
WE: General Management (Transportation)

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 07 Jun 2012, 04:11
AKProdigy87 wrote: The answer should be C: 5/8.
The initial probability of drawing a certain ball is the same as the probability of drawing that certain ball at any future point. Essentially, the "Expected" proportion of ball distribution for any round (3rd ball drawn, 4th ball drawn, etc.) is the same as the initial proportion. That was simply amazing My complicated version of your simple approach Let the 5 black balls be BBBBB and 3 Red Balls be RRR They can be arranged in 8 slots _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in (8!)/ (5!x3!) If the fourth slot is Black ball then the arrangement will be to fill _ _ _ B _ _ _ _ we have 7 slots and 4 Black (BBBB) and 3 Red (RRR) They can be arranged in (7!)/ (4!x3!) Hence required probability = [(7!)/ (4!x3!)] / [(8!)/ (5!x3!)] Ans = 5/8
Originally posted by manulath on 07 Jun 2012, 03:37.
Last edited by manulath on 07 Jun 2012, 04:11, edited 1 time in total.



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 58427

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Jun 2012, 12:36
A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one, every ball is selected at random without replacement. What is the probability that the fourth ball selected is black?A. 1/4 B. 1/2 C. 1/2 D. 5/8 E. 2/3 There is a shortcut solution for this problem: The initial probability of drawing black ball is 5/8. Without knowing the other results, the probability of drawing black ball will not change for ANY successive drawing: second, third, fourth... The same for yellow ball probability of drawing yellow ball is 3/8, the probability that 8th ball drawn is yellow is still 3/8. There is simply no reason to believe WHY is any drawing different from another (provided we don't know the other results). Similar questions to practice: aboxcontains3yellowballsand5blackballsonebyone90272.htmlabagcontains3whiteballs3blackballs2redballs100023.htmleachoffourdifferentlockshasamatchingkeythekeys101553.htmlif40peoplegetthechancetopickacardfromacanister97015.htmlnewsetofmixedquestions150204100.html#p1208473
_________________



Intern
Joined: 05 Sep 2011
Posts: 6

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Jun 2012, 05:39
Bunuel wrote: BarneyStinson wrote: Bunuel wrote: The initial probability of drawing black ball is 5/8. Without knowing the other results, the probability of drawing black ball will not change for ANY successive drawing: second, third, fourth... The same for yellow ball probability of drawing yellow ball is 3/8, the probability that 8th ball drawn is yellow is still 3/8. There is simply no reason to believe WHY is any drawing different from another (provided we don't know the other results).
Hope it's clear. Selected balls aren't replaced. The first ball to be black is 5/8 and to be yellow is 3/8. But, for the second ball selected to be black, it could still be 5/7 or 4/7. So, for the probability of third ball to be black, the first two could be black, or just one, or none could be black at all. Going by this counting technique..., I don't see how to calculate the fourth ball's probability to be black. Consider this: there are 8 cards, 5 spades, 3 hearts. What is the probability that the first card you pick will be spade? Clearly 5/8. Now next question, suppose I throw away three cards at random, not telling you which cards I thrown away. What is the probability NOW that you pick a spade out of 5 remaining cards? I've just reduced the sample from which you pick, but does the probability changed? WHY should it change? Another question, the same cards 5 spades and 3 hearts: I say that you can pick one card but only out of randomly selected 5 cards. What is the probability that the card you pick will be spade? I think there is no difference in ALL above cases and the probability will remain 5/8. If it changed, increased (or decreased), it would mean that the probability of picking heart on the other hand decreased (or increased). Why would it? @Bunuel please correct me if I am wrong "if it is said that first card is sprade, then what is the probability of the 3rd card would be a sprade? in this case we wouldn't consider initial probability?"



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 58427

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
27 Jun 2012, 02:06
marzan2011 wrote: Bunuel wrote: BarneyStinson wrote: Selected balls aren't replaced. The first ball to be black is 5/8 and to be yellow is 3/8. But, for the second ball selected to be black, it could still be 5/7 or 4/7. So, for the probability of third ball to be black, the first two could be black, or just one, or none could be black at all. Going by this counting technique..., I don't see how to calculate the fourth ball's probability to be black. Consider this: there are 8 cards, 5 spades, 3 hearts. What is the probability that the first card you pick will be spade? Clearly 5/8. Now next question, suppose I throw away three cards at random, not telling you which cards I thrown away. What is the probability NOW that you pick a spade out of 5 remaining cards? I've just reduced the sample from which you pick, but does the probability changed? WHY should it change? Another question, the same cards 5 spades and 3 hearts: I say that you can pick one card but only out of randomly selected 5 cards. What is the probability that the card you pick will be spade? I think there is no difference in ALL above cases and the probability will remain 5/8. If it changed, increased (or decreased), it would mean that the probability of picking heart on the other hand decreased (or increased). Why would it? @Bunuel please correct me if I am wrong "if it is said that first card is sprade, then what is the probability of the 3rd card would be a sprade? in this case we wouldn't consider initial probability?" If the first card is spade then we are left with 4 spades and 3 hearts and the probability that 3rd (or any other card) will be a spade is 4/7.
_________________



Director
Joined: 17 Dec 2012
Posts: 626
Location: India

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Jun 2013, 19:19
sgclub wrote: Bunuel, I don't get it even after reading the explanation. Aren't we reducing the total number of balls with each drawing? Consider 2 black balls and 1 white ball At the first draw, probability that the ball is black is 2/3 Once a ball is removed, remaining balls may be 1b and 1W, 1b and 1W or 2b At the second draw probability that the ball is black is, 1/3*1/2 + 1/3*1/2 + 1/3*1 = 2/3 We can see that the probability does not change even without replacement.
_________________
Srinivasan Vaidyaraman Sravna Test Prep http://www.sravnatestprep.comHolistic and Systematic Approach



Manager
Joined: 23 Apr 2018
Posts: 139

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Mar 2019, 03:36
Bunuel wrote: BarneyStinson wrote: Bunuel wrote: The initial probability of drawing black ball is 5/8. Without knowing the other results, the probability of drawing black ball will not change for ANY successive drawing: second, third, fourth... The same for yellow ball probability of drawing yellow ball is 3/8, the probability that 8th ball drawn is yellow is still 3/8. There is simply no reason to believe WHY is any drawing different from another (provided we don't know the other results).
Hope it's clear. Selected balls aren't replaced. The first ball to be black is 5/8 and to be yellow is 3/8. But, for the second ball selected to be black, it could still be 5/7 or 4/7. So, for the probability of third ball to be black, the first two could be black, or just one, or none could be black at all. Going by this counting technique..., I don't see how to calculate the fourth ball's probability to be black. Consider this: there are 8 cards, 5 spades, 3 hearts. What is the probability that the first card you pick will be spade? Clearly 5/8. Now next question, suppose I throw away three cards at random, not telling you which cards I thrown away. What is the probability NOW that you pick a spade out of 5 remaining cards? I've just reduced the sample from which you pick, but does the probability changed? WHY should it change?
Another question, the same cards 5 spades and 3 hearts: I say that you can pick one card but only out of randomly selected 5 cards. What is the probability that the card you pick will be spade? I think there is no difference in ALL above cases and the probability will remain 5/8. If it changed, increased (or decreased), it would mean that the probability of picking heart on the other hand decreased (or increased). Why would it? In the second explanation, if we reduce the sample size, how will probability be same as total number of outcomes will decrease from 8 to 5... as there are now, 5 cards only... why will it be 5/8 in this case too ?



Manager
Joined: 03 Sep 2018
Posts: 179

Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Sep 2019, 02:43
YYYBBBBB
Denominator = (8!)/(3!*5!) Numerator = (7!)/(3!*4!)




Re: A box contains 3 yellow balls and 5 black balls. One by one
[#permalink]
25 Sep 2019, 02:43






