Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Manager
Joined: 16 Feb 2011
Posts: 195
Schools: ABCD

A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Sep 2012, 07:36
Question Stats:
78% (01:42) correct
22% (01:09) wrong based on 124 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls and 7 Turquoise balls. Two balls are chosen from the jar. What is the probability that both balls chosen are Tan? A. 1/70 B. 2/49 C. 1/21 D. 6/441 E. 1/49 Don't we have to assume that the balls are identical? If they are, then the number of ways of choosing 2 Tan identical balls out of 3 tan balls = 1. Isn't it? If I assume that the balls are not withdrawn "at a time", OA is correct. However, how do I know whether the balls are withdrawn at a time or one by one?
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
Last edited by Bunuel on 01 Oct 2012, 07:22, edited 1 time in total.
Renamed the topic and edited the question.



Director
Joined: 22 Mar 2011
Posts: 612
WE: Science (Education)

Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Sep 2012, 10:12
3
This post received KUDOS
voodoochild wrote: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls and 7 Turquoise balls. Two balls are chosen from the jar. What is the probability that both balls chosen are Tan?
1) 1/70 2) 2/49 3) 1/21 4) 6/441 5) 1/49
Don't we have to assume that the balls are identical? If they are, then the number of ways of choosing 2 Tan identical balls out of 3 tan balls = 1. Isn't it? If I assume that the balls are not withdrawn "at a time", OA is correct. However, how do I know whether the balls are withdrawn at a time or one by one? The assumption is that balls of the same color are identical. OA answer is correct anyway. It doesn't matter that you stick both your hands in a jar and remove two balls together or get them onebyone. What matters is the final result: the types/colors of the two chosen balls. If you use probabilities: first ball Tan 3/21, second ball Tan 2/20, altogether (3/21)*(2/20) = 1/70. Combinatorics: total number of ways to choose 2 balls out of 21 is 21C2 = 21*20/2 = 21*10. Total number of ways to choose 2 Tan balls out of 3 is 3C2 = 3*2/2 = 3. Therefore, the required probability is 3/(21*10) = 1/70. Answer A.
_________________
PhD in Applied Mathematics Love GMAT Quant questions and running.



Manager
Joined: 16 Feb 2011
Posts: 195
Schools: ABCD

Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Sep 2012, 11:08
Ok. But what about this one: abaghas4blue3yellowand2greenballstheballsof139818.htmlIn this example, the number of ways of choosing any one out of 3 Yellow balls = 1+1+1+1 (no ball is chosen) instead of (3C0=1)+(3C1=3)+(3C2=3)+(3C3=1)=8 ways Can you please explain the difference between these two questions?



Manager
Joined: 16 Feb 2011
Posts: 195
Schools: ABCD

Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Oct 2012, 12:45
EvaJager wrote: voodoochild wrote: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls and 7 Turquoise balls. Two balls are chosen from the jar. What is the probability that both balls chosen are Tan?
1) 1/70 2) 2/49 3) 1/21 4) 6/441 5) 1/49
Don't we have to assume that the balls are identical? If they are, then the number of ways of choosing 2 Tan identical balls out of 3 tan balls = 1. Isn't it? If I assume that the balls are not withdrawn "at a time", OA is correct. However, how do I know whether the balls are withdrawn at a time or one by one? The assumption is that balls of the same color are identical. OA answer is correct anyway. It doesn't matter that you stick both your hands in a jar and remove two balls together or get them onebyone. What matters is the final result: the types/colors of the two chosen balls. If you use probabilities: first ball Tan 3/21, second ball Tan 2/20, altogether (3/21)*(2/20) = 1/70. Combinatorics: total number of ways to choose 2 balls out of 21 is 21C2 = 21*20/2 = 21*10. Total number of ways to choose 2 Tan balls out of 3 is 3C2 = 3*2/2 = 3. Therefore, the required probability is 3/(21*10) = 1/70. Answer A. Eva, Sorry to open this old thread. But, in this post : mathcombinatorics87345.html , the poster has mentioned that "Number of ways to pick 0 or more objects from n identical objects = n + 1"  Hence, the number of ways to pick 2 balls out of say 5 identical balls must NOT be 5C2  Correct? Please help me. thanks



Intern
Status: pg
Joined: 09 Dec 2011
Posts: 16
Location: Brazil

Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Oct 2012, 13:28
voodoochild wrote: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls and 7 Turquoise balls. Two balls are chosen from the jar. What is the probability that both balls chosen are Tan? A. 1/70 B. 2/49 C. 1/21 D. 6/441 E. 1/49 Don't we have to assume that the balls are identical? If they are, then the number of ways of choosing 2 Tan identical balls out of 3 tan balls = 1. Isn't it? If I assume that the balls are not withdrawn "at a time", OA is correct. However, how do I know whether the balls are withdrawn at a time or one by one? If it is not stated, we should assume without replacement, Therefore: 3/21 x 2/20 = 1/70 Answer A



Director
Joined: 22 Mar 2011
Posts: 612
WE: Science (Education)

Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Oct 2012, 15:49
1
This post received KUDOS
voodoochild wrote: EvaJager wrote: voodoochild wrote: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls and 7 Turquoise balls. Two balls are chosen from the jar. What is the probability that both balls chosen are Tan?
1) 1/70 2) 2/49 3) 1/21 4) 6/441 5) 1/49
Don't we have to assume that the balls are identical? If they are, then the number of ways of choosing 2 Tan identical balls out of 3 tan balls = 1. Isn't it? If I assume that the balls are not withdrawn "at a time", OA is correct. However, how do I know whether the balls are withdrawn at a time or one by one? The assumption is that balls of the same color are identical. OA answer is correct anyway. It doesn't matter that you stick both your hands in a jar and remove two balls together or get them onebyone. What matters is the final result: the types/colors of the two chosen balls. If you use probabilities: first ball Tan 3/21, second ball Tan 2/20, altogether (3/21)*(2/20) = 1/70. Combinatorics: total number of ways to choose 2 balls out of 21 is 21C2 = 21*20/2 = 21*10. Total number of ways to choose 2 Tan balls out of 3 is 3C2 = 3*2/2 = 3. Therefore, the required probability is 3/(21*10) = 1/70. Answer A. Eva, Sorry to open this old thread. But, in this post : mathcombinatorics87345.html , the poster has mentioned that "Number of ways to pick 0 or more objects from n identical objects = n + 1"  Hence, the number of ways to pick 2 balls out of say 5 identical balls must NOT be 5C2  Correct? Please help me. thanks The wording "Number of ways to pick 0 or more objects from n identical objects = n + 1" is not clear. It is meant that from n identical objects, we can choose none (which is 0), 1, 2,..., or all n objects  therefore we have n+1 choices. For example, if we have 5 identical balls, we can choose 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 balls. We have a total of 5 + 1 choices. Once we made up our mind how many balls we want to choose, say 2, then the number of possibilities to choose them is 5C2 = 5*4/2. Because, for the first ball 5 possibilities, for the second 4 possibilities, and then we have to divide by 2!, because the balls are identical, order doesn't matter (I would say it is meaningless, red is red, so why should I care which red I picked first?).
_________________
PhD in Applied Mathematics Love GMAT Quant questions and running.



Manager
Joined: 30 May 2013
Posts: 188
Location: India
Concentration: Entrepreneurship, General Management
GPA: 3.82

Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Aug 2013, 22:26
[/quote] Eva, Sorry to open this old thread. But, in this post : mathcombinatorics87345.html , the poster has mentioned that "Number of ways to pick 0 or more objects from n identical objects = n + 1"  Hence, the number of ways to pick 2 balls out of say 5 identical balls must NOT be 5C2  Correct? Please help me. thanks[/quote] The wording "Number of ways to pick 0 or more objects from n identical objects = n + 1" is not clear. It is meant that from n identical objects, we can choose none (which is 0), 1, 2,..., or all n objects  therefore we have n+1 choices. For example, if we have 5 identical balls, we can choose 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 balls. We have a total of 5 + 1 choices. Once we made up our mind how many balls we want to choose, say 2, then the number of possibilities to choose them is 5C2 = 5*4/2. Because, for the first ball 5 possibilities, for the second 4 possibilities, and then we have to divide by 2!, because the balls are identical, order doesn't matter (I would say it is meaningless, red is red, so why should I care which red I picked first?).[/quote] Hi, i have a small doubt in this. This example of 5 balls and pick up 2 ball can be written as like this also right Probablity to take first ball is : 2/5 Probablity to take second ball: 1/4 so independent event = 2/5* 1/4= 1/10 which is reciprocal of wat u got. . is this correct answer.? i am trying to understand this in probablity ways/ pleas healp me Thanks, Rrsnathan



MBA Section Director
Status: Back to work...
Affiliations: GMAT Club
Joined: 22 Feb 2012
Posts: 4396
Location: India
City: Pune
GPA: 3.4
WE: Business Development (Manufacturing)

Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Aug 2013, 23:49
Probability = \(\frac{Desired Outcomes}{Total Outcomes}\) Desired Outcomes = Number of ways of choosing 2 tan balls from 3 Tan balls = 3C2 Total Outcomes = Number of ways of choosing any 2 balls from 21 balls = 21C2 Thus Probability = \(\frac{3C2}{21C2}\) = \(\frac{1}{70}\)
_________________
Every Wednesday: Meet MBA Experts in Chat Room and Ask Your MostPressing MBA Admission Questions to them in a Live Chat.
Must Read Forum Topics Before You Kick Off Your MBA Application
New GMAT Club Decision Tracker  Real Time Decision Updates



Senior Manager
Joined: 10 Jul 2013
Posts: 334

Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls [#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Aug 2013, 01:33
1
This post received KUDOS
voodoochild wrote: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls and 7 Turquoise balls. Two balls are chosen from the jar. What is the probability that both balls chosen are Tan? A. 1/70 B. 2/49 C. 1/21 D. 6/441 E. 1/49 Don't we have to assume that the balls are identical? If they are, then the number of ways of choosing 2 Tan identical balls out of 3 tan balls = 1. Isn't it? If I assume that the balls are not withdrawn "at a time", OA is correct. However, how do I know whether the balls are withdrawn at a time or one by one? Both balls are tan = 3/21 × 2/20 = 1/70
_________________
Asif vai.....




Re: A jar contains 6 Magenta balls, 3 Tan balls, 5 Gray balls
[#permalink]
10 Aug 2013, 01:33







