Tricky question......
I found the easiest way to visualize it was to draw a line on the graph paper that is 12 cubes long.
1—2—3—4—5—6—7—8—9—10—11—12
We want the Ratio to be less than <
Shorter Piece : Longer Piece : TOTAL —> 1 : 3 : 4
(1st) start by looking where the cut would make the (S/L) Ratio exactly = 1/3
If we cut at point 3:
Short = 3
Long = 9
Therefore if we cut anywhere to the left of 3, that will give us the required Ratio < 1 : 3
Cutting at 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 would give us a Ratio of (short : long) that is GREATER than > 1/3
However if we make a cut at anywhere from 9 to 12, we again will have the required ratio.
From 3 - to - 1
+
From 9 - to - 12
_____________
Make up 6 of the 12 cuts
Therefore, 1/2 of the time we will end up with a Shorter Piece to Longer Piece Ratio that is less than < 1/3
Answer: probability = 1/2
Posted from my mobile device