Akela
A recent study of major motion pictures revealed that the vast majority of their plots were simply variations on plots that had been used many times before. Despite this fact, many people enjoy seeing several new movies each year.
Each of the following, if true, would contribute to an explanation of the apparent discrepancy in the information above EXCEPT:
(A) Movies based on standard plots are more likely to be financially successful than are ones based on original plots.
(B) If the details of their stories are sufficiently different, two movies with the same basic plot will be perceived by moviegoers as having different plots.
(C) Because of the large number of movies produced each year, the odds of a person seeing two movies with the same general plot structure in a five-year period are fairly low.
(D) A certain aesthetic pleasure is derived from seeing several movies that develop the same plot in slightly different ways.
(E) Although most modern movie plots have been used before, most of those previous uses occurred during the 1940s and 1950s.
Source: LSAT
Plots of major motion pics are simply variations on previous plots.
Still, many people see many new movies every year.
Which will explain and what will not explain this paradox?
(A) Movies based on standard plots are more likely to be financially successful than are ones based on original plots.
Could be the reason why same plots are used again and again but it doesn't tell us why people watch these. Doesn't explain. Answer.
(B) If the details of their stories are sufficiently different, two movies with the same basic plot will be perceived by moviegoers as having different plots.
Says that people perceive the plots are different even if basic plot is same. This could be why they keep watching the same plot again and again. Explains
(C) Because of the large number of movies produced each year, the odds of a person seeing two movies with the same general plot structure in a five-year period are fairly low.
It says that there are too many movies produced so even if people watch many movies, they don't usually get to see the same plot. Explains.
(D) A certain aesthetic pleasure is derived from seeing several movies that develop the same plot in slightly different ways.
Explains. There is aesthetic pleasure.
(E) Although most modern movie plots have been used before, most of those previous uses occurred during the 1940s and 1950s.
Explains. These plots were used many decades ago. So the modern movie goers may not have seen them before.
Answer (A)