A set of nonnegative integers consists of {x, x + 7, 2x, y, y + 5}.

Question

A set of nonnegative integers consists of {x, x + 7, 2x, y, y + 5}. The numbers of this set have four distinct values. What is its average (arithmetic mean)?

(1) x ≠ 5
(2) 4y + 12 = 6(y + 2)

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

A set of nonnegative integers consists of {x, x + 7, 2x, y, y + 5}. The numbers of this set have four distinct values. What is its average (arithmetic mean)?

Notice couple of things:
1. We are told that all numbers in the set are  integers ;
2. We are told that all those integers are  non-negative ;
3. We are told that the set contains four distinct values out of five (so two integers out of 5 are alike and other three are distinct).

(1) x ≠ 5. Clearly insufficient.

(2) 4y + 12 = 6(y + 2) --> 4y+12=6y+12 --> 2y=0 --> y=0. So, we have that our set is {x, x + 7, 2x, 0, 5}. Since we know that two integers out of 5 are alike then:

1. x, x+7 or 2x is 0. 
If x=0, then 2x=0 too, so in this case we'll have three alike integers x, 2x, and y. Thus this case is out.
If x+7=0, then x=-7 and we know that all integers must be non-negative so this case is out too.

2. x, x+7 or 2x is 5
 If x=5, then x+7=12 and 2x=10. This scenario is OK. The set in this case would be: {5, 12, 10, 0, 5} 
If x+7=5, then x=-2 and we know that the integers in the set must be non-negative. Thus this case is out.
If 2x=5, then x=5/2 and we know that the numbers in the set must be integers. Thus this case is out.

3. Two out of x, x+7 and 2x are alike.
x=2x is not possible, since in this case x=2x=0 and in this case we'll have three alike integers x, 2x, and y.
x=x+7 has no solution.
 2x=x+7 --> x=7. This scenario is OK. The set in this case would be: {7, 14, 14, 0, 5}.

Two cases are possible. Not sufficient.

(1)+(2) Since from (1) x ≠ 5, then from (2) x=7. So, the set is {7, 14, 14, 0, 5}. Sufficient.

Answer: C.

Hope it's clear.

siddharthismu87 · Answer

Hi, It goes like this: Statement 1: X not equal to 5, Which is INSUFFICIENT as we need to know the value of Y. Statement 2 says: 4y+12=6y+12 Solving STATEMENT 2, We get Y=0, Hence the series become, X, X+7, 2X, 0, 5 Now, we know that 2 numbers are identical, Which arises following possibilities: 1: x=2x Which means X=0, (But this is not possible as Three numbers in the series will be equal, which refuted the given condition) 2: X+7=2x, which means, X=7 3: X=5 4: X+7=5, (This is also not possible as it gives negative values of X) So Statement 2 says either X=7 or X=5, So Statement 2 is also Insufficient, Combining bo S 1 and 2, X=7, Hence C..

EvaJager · Answer

(1) If x = 0, the numbers are 0, 7, 0, y, y + 5.
If we take y different from 0, 7 and 2, for sure we get four distinct values. Therefore, we cannot know the average of the numbers.
For example y = 1: 0, 7, 0, 1, 6, for y = 10 - 0, 7, 0, 10, 15.
Not sufficient.

(2) From the given equality, y = 0.
We have the numbers x, x + 7, 2x, 0, 5.
x cannot be 0 - 0, 7, 0, 0, 5 - only 3 distinct values
x can be 5 - 5, 12, 10, 0, 5 - exactly 4 distinct values
x can be 7 - 7, 14, 14, 0, 5 - exactly 4 distinct values
Not sufficient.

(1) and (2) together:
If x is not 5, and x cannot be 0, then x, 2x, 0, and 5 are distinct numbers. It means that x + 7 must be one of them.
Since x + 7 > x, x + 7 > 0, x + 7 > 5 (x is positive), the only possibility left is x + 7 = 2x, from which x = 7.
The numbers are 7, 14, 14, 0, 5.
Sufficient.

Answer C.

Bunuel · Answer

Bumping for review and further discussion*. Get a kudos point for an    alternative    solution!

*New project from GMAT Club!!! Check  HERE

mau5 · Answer

From F.S 1, all we know is that x ≠ 5. Now as there are 4 distinct values, any 2 of the elements have to be exactly same. Thus, we can have :

x = 2x --> x= 0 OR x+7 = 2x--> x = 7. 
In both cases we could assume the value of y = 1 and have the set as (0,7,0,1,6)--> Average = 14/5 = 2.8 OR the set would be (7,14,14,1,6) --> Average = 42/5 = 8.4.

Thus,even after adhering to the condition given in the F.S; as we are getting two different values for average-->Insufficient.

From F.S 2, we know that y=0. Thus, the set reads as (x,x+7,2x,0,5).

To make the elements assume 4 distinct values, we can set x = 5, and have the set as (5,12,10,0,5)
We could also assume x = 7 just as above and get the set as (7,14,14,0,5). Again, Insufficient.

Taking both the fact statements together, we now know that x = 7. Sufficient.

C.

ziko · Answer

An interesting question.

1statement) It tells us tha x does not equal to 5, lets take x=1 and y=1 (I am taking these numbers because in the question stem i see that there are four distinct numbers but we have five numbers, this means that two out of five numbers should be identical, so it is easier to take x and y as the same numbers. But to make this question even clearer i would add the word EXACTLY or ONLY four distinct numbers) then we have 1; 8; 2; 1; 6. If we take x=2 and y=2 then we have 2; 9; 4; 2; 7. Two sets which satisfies the question conditions of having four distinct numbers. Not sufficient.

2 statement) if we solve the equation it tells us that y=0. In this case we have last two numbers: 0 and 5. Lets see what are possible other numbers. We have x; x+7 and 2x. According to the question conditions there should be four distinct numbers, in order that to happen x should be equal to 5 or to 7, because in other cases we would have more than 4 distinct numbers or less than 4 distinct numbers. Two possible options - not sufficient.

Combining both statements we see that x does not equall to 5 then it means it is equall to 7. Both statements together are sufficient - choice C.

MahBir · Answer

I miss-read the second stmt, but I think this can be an alternate question where stmt 2 is alone sufficient
 (1) x ≠ 5
 (2) 4x + 12 = 6(y + 2)
Came up with answer B – please let me know if my approach is right here.

Set: {x, x + 7, 2x, y, y + 5}
Stmt 2 gives: 4x=6y i.e. 2x=3y hence x ≠ y or y ≠ 2x
Given that all are integers and are non-negative, hence x ≠ 2x, so from above set only 2 possible scenarios
1. y=x+7 (when combined with 2x=3y) leads to x = -21 -negative -not possible
2. x=y+5 (when combined with 2x=3y) leads to y = 10
so the set becomes {15, 22, 30, 10, 15}
hence answer is B

Divyadisha · Answer

We are given 5 non-negative integers and told that 4 are distinct numbers. That means there are two integers that are same.

(1) x ≠ 5. We don't know about y. not sufficient.

(2) 4y + 12 = 6(y + 2)
Solving this equation we get the value of y=5

But we don't know the value of x. Hence not sufficient.

Combining both statements:-
y=5
y+5=10

one value from x, x + 7, 2x is 5 or 10 
We know x is not equal to 5
which means 2x is not equal to 10
x+7=10 
x= 3

And now we can calculate the average. C is the answer

nahid78 · Answer

A tough one.. Kudos to bunuel for such nice explanation.

newyork2012 · Answer

(1) x ≠ 5 not sufficient
(2) 4y + 12 = 6(y + 2) => y=0 still not sufficient

1 and 2 together {x, x + 7, 2x, 0, 5}. only four distinct values ,at the same time x ≠ 5 ===> x≠0 ,but we need to have 2 same numbers ,so 2x = x+7 ====> x=7

so {7, 7 + 7, 2*7, 0, 5} ..easy to get the mean

c

CrackverbalGMAT · Answer

Q.stem says: The set has non negative integers(so 0 included) & two are identical(since 4 of 5 elements are distinct).
To find mean,we need to know the elements in the set.

#St1: x not equal to 5 gives us no information on y.
Insufficient. Eliminate A,D

#St2: 4y + 12 = 6(y+2)
So y=0 and hence two of the elements are 0 and 5(y+5).

Can we have another 0 as x?
In that case x,2x,y would all be 0.3 identical elements. Not possible.

Can we have another 5 as x?
In that case the set {x,x+7,2x,y,y+5} would be {5,12,10,0,5}

Two elements identical. Possible.
Can we have the terms x+7 and 2x identical?

So x+7 = 2x ? ( Two elements identical)
Then the set is {7,14,14,0,5}.Possible.

Thus no definite answer from st2.Eliminate B.
Combine 1 & 2,

You have x as 7 as it cannot be 5(st 1)
So {7,14,14,0,5}

(Sufficient)
 (option c) 
  D.S
GMAT SME

Sushen · Answer

C Q: What is the mean? 
 --{x,x+7,2x,y,y+5}
 --All NON-Negative integers
 --Two of those integers are alike and the other 3 all different.

(1) x≠5 Simply Not Sufficient. 
 
(2) 4y+12=6y+12 y=0
 {x,x+7,2x,0,5}
Limitations: x+7≠0 (all non-negative. X would be -7)
 x≠0, 2x≠0 (Only 2 values are the same)
 x≠x+7

Possibilities: 
 If x=7, we would have 4 values and could calculate a mean.
 If x = 1, we would have 4 values and we could calculate a mean
 BUT, these means would be DIFFERENT. I CANNOT determine the mean of this set.
 Not Sufficient

TOGETHER: 
x≠0 or 5 x≠2x (that would mean x=0, see above. Can^' t be true.
SO, x+7=2x and x=7 and we CAN calculate the mean.

Sufficient-----> C is the answer!

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

A set of nonnegative integers consists of {x, x + 7, 2x, y, y + 5}.

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

A set of nonnegative integers consists of {x, x + 7, 2x, y, y + 5}.

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards