A vendor sold an item after reducing the price of the item by p percent from its original price. If the cost of the item to the vendor was $80, did the vendor make a profit on the sale of the item?To make a profit, the vendor would have had to sell the item for more than the vendor's cost of $80. So, we can simplify the question to "Did the vendor sell the item for more than $80?'
(1) The original price of the item was greater than $105.This statement limits the price before the reduction to values greater than $105 but does not limit how much the price was reduced by.
Given what this statement says,
p could be any percentage.
So, the information provided by this statement does not at all restrict the price at which the item was sold.
Insufficient.
(2) p < 25This statement tells us the percentage by which the price was reduced from the original price.
However, it does not indicate what the original price was. So, given what this statement says, the vendor could have sold the item for any price.
Insufficient.
Statements (1) and (2) combinedThe statements combined are a little tricky to handle because we could see that statement (1) says that the original price was greater than $105 and that statement (2) says that
p < 25 and decide that $105 - (something less than 25) must be greater than $80 since 105 - 25 = 80.
So, what's key to notice is that 25 percent of 105 isn't 25. It's (0.25 × 100) + (0.25 × 5) = 26.25.
Accordingly, 105 - (0.25 × 105) = 78.75.
Thus, even if the original price was slightly over $105 and
p was slightly less than 25, the item could have been sold for less than $80.
Example:
Original price: 105.01
p: 24.99
Final selling price: 105.01 × 0.7501 ≈ 78.77
We don't need to calculate the above example to see that we can increase the original price by a small amount from $105 and decrease
p from 25 by a small amount and still get a selling price below $80. After all, there's room for a small increase between 78.75 and 80.
At the same time, we can also see that, if we sufficiently increase the original price or decrease
p, we can get a final selling price above $80.
So, given the information provided by the statements combined, the final selling price could be below or above $80.
Insufficient.
Correct answer E