chetan2u wrote:
According to a prominent investment adviser, Company X has a 50% chance of posting a profit in the coming year, whereas Company Y has a 60% chance of posting a profit in the coming year.
Select for
Least probability for both the least probability, compatible with the probabilities provided by the investment adviser, that both Company X and Company Y will post a profit in the coming year. And select for
Greatest probability for both the greatest probability, compatible with the probabilities provided by the investment adviser, that both Company X and Company Y will post a profit in the coming year. Make only two selections, one in each column.
We do not know the relation between the two events. We cannot say that they must be independent. Whay if both companies have the same suppliers and markets? There could be a strong correlation between their chance of posting profits. Or the two companies could be totally independent. The point is, we do not know the relation between the two events.
Probability works just as Sets does.
Minimum:Both and Neither move together. For Both to be minimum, Neither = 0
P(X or Y) = P(X) + P(Y) - P(Both)
P(X or Y) = .5 + .6 - P(Both)
For P(Both) to be minimum, P(X or Y) must be maximum i.e. 1.
1 = .5 + .6 - P(Both)
P(Both) = .1
Maximum:P(Both) cannot be greater than either one individually so maximum value of P(Both) will be .5
Hence, select 10% and 50%.
How Both and Neither work together in Overlapping Sets is discussed in
this video on my
YouTube channel.